90.9 WBUR - Boston's NPR news station
PLEDGE NOW


























MAY GOD HAVE MERCY
by John C. Tucker

Previous - Chapter II: Brad and Wanda - Next

BUY THE BOOK
Read a Review

Wanda Fay Thompson was born on November 5, 1961, the second youngest of 16 children, 8 girls and 8 boys. Wanda's father is a retired coal miner. The Thompsons raised their sixteen children in a frame house on Home Creek, a small tributary of Levisa Fork about twelve miles northwest of Grundy, almost to Kentucky.

The family has always been close. All of the sons are in some kind of coal mining job, and two of them, Pal and Danny Ray, have built their own houses on the hill just above the house where they were raised and their mother and father still live. Most of the other children live close by. All of the girls are pretty, and Wanda, with her deep red hair and ready smile was no exception. Although she enjoyed the outdoor games her brothers and sisters played together whenever chores and good weather permitted, Wanda's favorite pastime was making clothes and crafts. In high school she was an average student, quiet and obedient. With strangers, she was almost painfully shy. No one can recall her ever doing anything mean or hurtful. Her sister Peggy, struggling for words to describe Wanda, finally says "I guess you'd have to say she was just about perfect."

Wanda Fay Thompson at age 15. (Photo Courtesy John Tucker)

Brad McCoy is Max "Hezzie" McCoy's youngest son. Hezzie works for United Coal and drives a white stretch limousine which he rents out and chauffeurs himself for weddings and other occasions. He is a proud member of the McCoy clan. Brad is slight of build and as soft spoken and gentle as his legendary forbears were crude and ill-tempered.


Brad McCoy and Wanda Fay Thompson were high school sweethearts at Grundy Senior High School. Brad was the class of 1978, Wanda, two years behind him. They met through Wanda's older sister Lydia, who worked with Brad at the Piggly Wiggly. Brad had a crush on Lydia, but she passed him off to her younger sister.

The pass was complete. In July, a few weeks after Brad graduated, Brad McCoy and Wanda Fay Thompson were married at the Grundy Baptist Church. Wanda's family attended a church on Home Creek, but Brad had become close to Rev. Jack Mutter, the minister at Grundy Baptist whose son, a close friend of Brad's, had been killed in a car accident not long before. It was typical of Brad that he would think it might give Mutter some comfort to celebrate the wedding of his son's friend, and Wanda and her parents agreed to his request that the ceremony be held at Grundy Baptist. Bill Pierce, a friend, stood up for Brad. Wanda was attended by her younger sister Patricia. Both sets of parents thought the marriage was a perfect match, and for as long as it lasted it seemed they were right.

On June 16th, three days after Brad graduated from High School he went to work at United Coal. Perhaps because of his temperament and slight build, or perhaps because he seemed a little smarter than the average Grundy High School graduate, Brad was employed above ground, as a parts clerk in one of the company repair shops.

Wanda and Brad at Brad's high school prom. (Photo Courtesy John Tucker)

If you turn left at the Grundy stop light and follow Route 460 toward Kentucky, in about two miles you come to United Coal Shop No. 1, where Brad McCoy was assigned. If you turn right at the light and follow the road toward West Virginia, the narrow valley formed by Slate Creek widens a bit about three quarters of a mile east of town. There a bridge spans the creek and leads into a small subdivision called Longbottom. The first two rows back from the creek are well kept brick and frame ranch homes whose middle class owners are likely to be teachers, shop owners or coal company supervisors. Farther back a few older frame houses are more typical of the area's working class population. In 1980 Hezzie and Betty McCoy lived in one of those houses, and after they were married, Brad and Wanda were able to rent another one, less than two blocks from Brad's mother and father.

When they were married, Wanda thought she might return to high school in the fall, but she soon found she enjoyed the life of a housewife. Brad's salary was enough to sustain their simple needs, and Wanda decided to drop out of school. Working, keeping house, visiting friends and family, Brad and Wanda settled into the rented house in Longbottom and remained there until the night Wanda Fay McCoy was murdered.

Continue : Read Chapter III



Home | Death Row Stories | Science of DNA | Law & Politics
Inside Out | Credits | WBUR