90.9 WBUR - Boston's NPR news station
Top Stories:

Question 4

Are you in your position because of your actions or the economy?

Photo prompt #4: Use ten objects to illustrate how much of your current situation you attribute to your actions and how much to the economy. On the left: your actions; on the right: the economy.

There’s a bit in one of my favorite books, “A Wrinkle in Time,” where Mrs. Whatsit compares human life to a sonnet. Unlike other types of verse, a Shakespearean sonnet has rather strict rules: fourteen lines, in iambic pentameter, with a prescribed rhyme scheme. Yet the author has freedom within that structure.

Or, as Mrs. Whatsit says: “You’re given the form, but you have to write the sonnet yourself. What you say is completely up to you.” Whenever I feel like a victim of circumstance, I try to remember that passage.

My own situation is limited by some things beyond my control — the class I was born into, the current economic climate, pure luck — and I have unearned privileges thanks to my race and health and sexual orientation, to name just a few. But I am writing my sonnet just the same.

I think it’s pretty rich for older folks to call us the “entitlement” generation at the same time that unpaid internships, about 99 percent of which I’d hazard are illegal according to OSHA guidelines, have become the norm. How entitled can we be, really, if we don’t even demand to be paid for the work that we do? Bitching on Facebook isn’t exactly marching on Washington.

You would think that folks coming from the “Me! Generation” might be hesitant to label the young as universally spoiled good-for-nothings, but there you go. The wheel of generational conflict spins on.

Younger people will always be seen as ungrateful and spoiled, and the older generation will always hold all of the actual political and economic power until the younger generation inherits it and can label the
newest crop of twenty-somethings as “entitled.” And so on and so on, forever ad nauseum, amen.

Plus, “entitlement” is pretty a pretty meaningless zinger anyway.

I think Jon Stewart hit upon it best: “They’re really only entitlements when they’re something other people want. When it’s something you want, they’re a hallmark of a civilized society.”

I do not feel “entitled” to a society where people are fairly paid for the work they do and where we provide a safety net for people going through hard times. I just think it’s a very, very good idea.


  1. Roxanne Palmer at 12:32 pm, October 19, 2012

    Belatedly, I realize that I left the sixth book out of the left stack in the picture. So let us say that the 10th object is the dish towel, which for our purposes we shall imagine is, oh, I don’t know, the playing field of Life I guess?

    I’d like to note that the right stack, though containing fewer books, is much heavier. Take from that what you will.

  2. Lesley at 12:55 am, October 22, 2012

    I don’t think this generation is entitled. Historically, there’s always someone in every generation who thinks that the subsequent generation is worse. It’s pure nonsense. Worse, schmorse. I think this generation is doing quite well, thank you very much, under extraordinary hardships and turmoil.