Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Last Bell

Last Bell: Charlie Baker on Early Education, Malden Student a finalist in Google Doodle Competition, Testing Here and Abroad, and Charter School Funding

Republican gubernatorial candidate Charlie Baker briefly discussed education with The Berkshire Eagle this week, saying advancements in early education are meaningless without strong upper-level public schools.

The Eagle quotes Baker as saying:

"If we're going to be strategic about how we approach the early childhood ed piece, we've got to make sure that the kids coming out of that are heading into an elementary school, a middle school and a high school that's a performer.

"A lot of studies show that whatever the gains are in early childhood ed they fade pretty fast if the kids aren't in schools that perform at a reasonably high level."

—

A young student from Mystic Valley Regional Charter School in Malden has put herself in position to potentially win a $30,000 scholarship and a $50,000 grant for her school, Malden Patch reports.

Isabel Waller is the Massachusetts nominee for the Doodle 4 Google contest, for which she designed a Google logo that depicts a device that turns garbage into flowers, according to Patch.

Of the contest, Google says, "One talented young artist (grades K-12) will see his or her artwork on the Google homepage and receive a $30,000 college scholarship and a $50,000 Google for Education technology grant for his or her school."

—

Testing, testing, testing. A common critique of the American education system is that students are over-tested, but NPR looked internationally and found that students in some countries are tested sometimes as much and often in higher-pressure situations.

For instance, NPR reported, a number of countries have colleges that base admittance on entry exams.

In the U.S., only about half of states have anything resembling a high-stakes, high school exit exam. And American colleges and universities do consider report cards, teacher recommendations and those obligatory application essays. In fact, hundreds of U.S. schools no longer require test scores at all.

So do American teens take more tests than kids overseas? It's distinctly possible. But those kids overseas would argue: When it comes to stress, it's not the quantity of tests that matters but what's at stake when the clock starts ticking.

—

The Economist's Democracy in America blog looked at charter school funding in a blog post Wednesday and took issue with common rhetoric about the distribution of education funds.

"In the bitter debate about charter schools, one of the myths perpetuated by critics is that charters are generously funded by rich donors," The Economist wrote, referencing a recent op-ed that contended charter schools do not operate more efficiently than public schools but instead have more money.

This is wrong, and badly so. Research has been mounting that shows that charter schools have in fact less money than their public rivals. This financial imbalance is confirmed by a new report from the University of Arkansas, published in the Journal of School Choice. The study looks at the total available revenue for traditional and public charter schools in 30 states and 48 major cities in the 2010-11 school year. In all states, except Tennessee, charter schools receive less money per pupil than traditional public schools. Sometimes this deficit is small. New Mexico charter schools receive only $365 less per pupil. Other times it is enormous. In Washington, DC, charter schools receive $12,736 less per pupil. Across the 48 major urban areas examined (where charter schools are more common), the deficit between public and charter schools was about $4,352 per pupil. The gap is smaller if averaged across all charter schools in the country, at $3,814. Still, this is a funding gap of 28%.

Why does this matter? For one, according to The Economist, "If charter schools are receiving nearly one-third less funding per pupil, on average, one has to wonder whether they are being set up for failure. Critics often complain that charter schools are less helpful to students with special needs, and less lenient when students misbehave. Charters are more likely than public schools to expel difficult pupils. The money gap explains some of this: with fewer resources to manage problematic pupils, charters can’t afford to be more helpful or more forgiving."