Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Explainer

Massachusetts' School-To-Prison Pipeline, Explained

As a result of school discipline policies, students of color and students with disabilities are intertwined with the school-to-prison pipeline (Carlos Osorio/AP)
As a result of school discipline policies, students of color and students with disabilities are intertwined with what has been termed a "school-to-prison pipeline." (Carlos Osorio/AP)

The use of exclusionary school discipline -- out-of-school suspension, expulsion, referral to law enforcement or school-related arrest -- can have lasting effects that push students toward the criminal justice system later in life, a process that has been termed the "school-to-prison pipeline."

Here is the "school-to-prison pipeline" explained, and its impact in Massachusetts schools.

What is the school-to-prison pipeline?

Simply put, data shows that zero-tolerance policies and repeated school discipline can push students out of school and lead to repeated arrest and incarceration.

Here it is, by the numbers:

Children who have been expelled or suspended from school once are much more likely to be disciplined similarly again, and twice as likely than their peers to drop out, according to a study by the Civil Rights Project at UCLA. Students who are arrested at school are three times more likely to drop out than their peers.

Students who drop out of school are then eight times more likely to end up in the criminal justice system than students who graduate. A study of Massachusetts felons found that offenders who had at least one juvenile arraignment were more likely to be re-convicted of a crime within 3 years of being released from prison.

School environments with zero-tolerance policies -- strict disciplinary codes for any student who breaks the rules -- can have long-term impacts that, advocates say, set students on a path that can end behind bars.

Who is affected?

Students of color and students with disabilities absorb a disproportional impact of school discipline policies.

Black students in Massachusetts schools are almost four times more likely than white peers to be suspended from school and Latino students are 3 times more likely than white students to be suspended -- often for minor offenses, according to a 2014 study.

Students of color are more likely to be disciplined for subjective offenses, such as defiance, disrespect or dress code violations, according to Matt Cregor, co-author of a report on Massachusetts school discipline. White students, on the other hand, are more likely be punished for documented offenses like alcohol possession, smoking or vandalism.

Schools with more black students tend to have higher rates of suspension, in general. A 2010 study by researchers at Villanova University showed that nationally, the severity of a school's discipline policy was positively correlated with the percentage of students that were black, not juvenile delinquency or drug use.

In Massachusetts, during the 2012-2013 school year, black students received 43 percent of all out-of-school suspensions and 39 percent of expulsions, despite making up less than 9 percent of students enrolled.

Nationally, discipline differences across race lines for students with disabilities are vast: 1 in 4 black children with disabilities are suspended, compared to 1 in 11 white students.

School discipline and educational disparities mirror a stark reality of the criminal justice system: only 7 percent of Massachusetts residents are black, yet 28 percent of the people behind bars in Massachusetts are black.

From 1997 to 2007, the number of law enforcement personnel stationed in schools increased by more than a third nationally. (Wilfredo Lee/AP)
From 1997 to 2007, the number of law enforcement personnel stationed in schools increased by more than a third nationally. (Wilfredo Lee/AP)

How did we get here?

Many policies and practices can be pointed toward to explain why students of color and students with disabilities disproportionately absorb the impacts of school discipline.

According to the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), "second-rate" educational environments -- schools with overcrowded classrooms, a lack of qualified teachers, insufficient funding for services -- can be a beginning. Failure to meet educational needs increases disengagement and at-risk behavior.

Other primary factors include the adoption of zero-tolerance discipline policies and the presence of law enforcement in schools.

Vox provides some national context:

The Gun-Free Schools Act, passed in 1994, mandated a yearlong out-of-school suspension for any student caught bringing a weapon to school. And as states began adopting these zero-tolerance policies, the number of suspensions and expulsions increased. The suspension rate for all students has nearly doubled since the 1970s, and has increased even more for black and Hispanic students.

Zero-tolerance policies have been widely criticized when schools have interpreted "weapon" very broadly, expelling students for making guns with their fingers or chewing a Pop-Tart into a gun shape or bringing a camping fork for Cub Scouts to class.

But they're not the only reason schools suspended students more frequently. At the same time as zero-tolerance policies for violence were growing, school districts adopted their own version of the broken windows theory of policing. The broken windows theory emphasizes the importance of cracking down on small offenses in order to make residents feel safer and discourage more serious crimes; in schools, it translated into more suspensions for offenses that previously hadn't warranted them — talking back to teachers, skipping class, or being otherwise disobedient or disruptive.

As policies for student conduct became more strict, school districts also began to station actual police officers in schools.

From 1997 to 2007, the amount of law enforcement stationed in schools increased by more than a third nationally. According to the National Association of School Resource Officers, school-based policing is presently "the fastest growing area of law enforcement."

In 2008, Boston Public Schools had the 12th largest number of full-time law enforcement personnel of any school district in the country.

An ACLU report of school policing in Massachusetts' three largest school districts -- Boston, Springfield, and Worcester (all predominantly low-income districts with majority students of color) -- found "numerous arrests at school during the school day based on misbehavior that could have been addressed more appropriately by teachers and school staff, and with significantly less harm to students."

The report found that in Springfield, most public order arrests involved youth who refused to obey directives in a "verbally confrontational manner."

This means students who swore or exhibited other disrespectful behavior towards teachers, police officers or other adults were arrested and charged with a crimes such as "disorderly conduct," "disturbing a lawful assembly," or "violating codes of conduct."

An example from Springfield:

In 2007, a boy at Kennedy Middle School was found with a cell phone in his book bag in violation of school policy. School administrators confiscated the phone and told the student that his mother would have to come to the school to retrieve it. The student then started “walking around the office” and stated that he needed his “f-cking phone.” The student was warned that he was becoming disruptive, but continued to swear and state that he needed his phone. He was advised that he was going to be arrested, stated that he did not care, and was then handcuffed and told to sit down. He was charged with disturbing a lawful assembly.

The report concluded that policing practices disproportionately affect the same two groups of students most influenced by school discipline: students of color and students with behavioral or learning disabilities.

Boston Community Leadership Academy pilot high school seniors seen working through the window of their classroom door. (Stephan Savoia/AP)
Boston Community Leadership Academy pilot high school seniors seen working through the window of their classroom door. (Stephan Savoia/AP)

How could high-stakes testing be a part of it?

With the adoption of the federal No Child Left Behind standards in 2002, states were required to develop assessments to test skills in reading, math and science. In Massachusetts students must pass 10th grade standardized assessments in order to graduate. Teacher evaluations are often tied to student test scores.

Due to the high-stakes consequences attached to testing, some say a shift in school cultures has appeared.

A four-year investigation into whether school discipline could be used to reshape testing pools in Florida public schools, found that during testing periods low-performing students often received substantially harsher suspensions than high-performing peers for similar offences.

What is being done about it?

Civil rights advocates, parents, policy makers and school officials have turned an eye toward addressing the disproportionate effects of school discipline.

In August 2012, Massachusetts passed a law, commonly referred to as Chapter 222, to prevent the unnecessary exclusion of students from school.

In response, districts have developed updated codes of conduct aligned to Chapter 222 rules. Boston's code of conduct, for example, requires progressive measures of discipline before suspension. In the result of a suspension or expulsion, the district must provide continued educational services.

Individual schools and districts have turned toward restorative justice measures, which are designed to enfranchise youth, instead of zero-tolerance policies and suspensions.

Restorative justice measures include written apologies, conferences between offenders and victims, anger management courses, or enrollment in intervention and prevention programs.

While the law and restorative justice techniques have led to a reduction in discipline practices statewide, students of color and students with disabilities still remain disproportionately affected.

Related coverage

Reporter's Notebook

School Network With Most Kindergarten Suspensions Says It Will Stop Them

BOSTON -- Kindergarten and pre-kindergarten students were suspended 78 times at schools operated by a single nonprofit school management company in the 2014-15 school year, according to state data.

Now, the Boston-based UP Education Network says it will ban suspensions for their youngest students starting Wednesday.

"As a result of an internal evaluation of our practices, UP has decided to no longer issue suspensions to students in kindergarten," Victoria Criado, UP Education Network spokesperson, said by email.

UP Education Network specializes in school turnaround for formerly underperforming schools. Since 2010, the school network has restarted five schools in Boston and Lawrence. Some are in-district charters.

Read more of School Network With Most Kindergarten Suspensions Says It Will Stop Them →

Reporter's Notebook

Mass. Had Hundreds Of Suspensions Last Year — In Kindergarten And Pre-K

BOSTON -- Massachusetts public and charter schools suspended kindergarten and pre-kindergarten students 603 times in the 2014-15 school year, a WBUR analysis of state data shows.

Students in their first year of school were sent home for offenses that included hitting, disrupting, disrespecting, throwing things and fighting.

Dolores Michel's son Dashon got one of those 603 punishments. He was suspended from school before he could read, write or tie his shoes.

"Oh, the first time was incredible ... that was early last year," Michel says. "They call me and tell me that my son had done this and done that and you need to come and pick him up right away. And I'm saying, 'What did he do?'"

When Michel got to her son's school in Dorchester, she found out. After Dashon got off the bus, he pushed to the front of a line. He wanted to be the first student in class.

"The teacher didn't want him to cut in front of the other student, so the teacher [had] him wait outside," Michel says.

Read more of Mass. Had Hundreds Of Suspensions Last Year — In Kindergarten And Pre-K →

Reporter's Notebook

Why Boston Students Created A ‘Know Your Rights’ App

BOSTON -- A group of Boston Public School students have turned to the power and popularity of technology to empower peers to be aware of their rights while in school.

They’ve recently released the website and mobile phone app Boston Student Rights, which presents the district's student code of conduct in a condensed, simplified format. It includes information on subjects ranging from types of suspensions to cellphone policies, LGBTQ students' rights, teacher evaluations and dress codes.

Most importantly, the app also shares information on proper school discipline processes, highlights students' own rights and responsibilities as laid out by state law, and lists out legal aid resources available for students.

Read more of Why Boston Students Created A ‘Know Your Rights’ App →

Reporter's Notebook

Reforming The Use Of Physical Restraints And Seclusion In Massachusetts Schools

Gail Merriam's daughter was in first grade when, lying on the floor, she told her mother she didn't want to live anymore.

The daughter, who was enrolled in a program for students with behavioral challenges at the John F. Kennedy Elementary School in Somerville, Massachusetts, had become scared to go to school, depressed and suicidal, her mother said.

"She lay down on the floor upstairs one day and said, 'I don't want to live anymore, I want to kill myself,'" Merriam recalled during an interview last month, her eyes filled with a pain that betrayed an otherwise strong composure. "I ended up having to hospitalize her."

Merriam believes it was the use of physical restraints at the school that caused her daughter's suicidal thoughts.

Read more of Reforming The Use Of Physical Restraints And Seclusion In Massachusetts Schools →

Reporter's Notebook

Report: Black Girls Face Disproportionate Punishment In Boston Schools

BOSTON -- Black girls in Boston's schools face much harsher school discipline than their white peers but are often overlooked in school reform efforts, a new report says.

The report, by the African American Policy Forum and Columbia Law School’s Center for Intersectionality and Social Policy Studies (CISPS), found that the number of disciplinary cases involving black girls were 11 times more than cases involving their white counterparts, despite there being less than three times as many black students in Boston schools.

"When it comes to school discipline, black girls face a greater risk of racial discrimination and disparity than any other group," said Kimberle Williams Crenshaw, the executive director of CISPS and professor of Law at Columbia University and UCLA. Crenshaw is the lead author on the report.

Read more of Report: Black Girls Face Disproportionate Punishment In Boston Schools →

Reporter's Notebook

Report: Black And Latino Students On A Separate, Lesser Educational Track In Boston

White and Asian male students in Boston's schools are 1.2 times more likely to graduate than their black male peers and 1.4 times more likely than Latino males in the district, according to a city-commissioned report released Thursday.

In what some are calling an educational crisis, the report outlines that black and Latino males are lagging substantially behind peers on MCAS scores, high school graduation and attendance rates, while outperforming peers in suspension and dropout rates.

Read more of Report: Black And Latino Students On A Separate, Lesser Educational Track In Boston →

A good school is ...

Civil Rights Groups Call For A Better Measure Of Accountability In Public Education

The country's current education system is placing "tremendous burden on schools disproportionately serving low-income students and students of color" and leaving them under-resourced and ill-prepared, charged a coalition of civil rights groups in a letter to President Barack Obama, Education Secretary Arne Duncan, congressional and state educational leaders.

Eleven civil rights groups released the letter Tuesday urging improved accountability at the local, state, and federal levels in order to increase equity and opportunity for students of color. The group wants to see government officials implement measures beyond high-stakes testing to make sure schools are serving students well.

Read more of Civil Rights Groups Call For A Better Measure Of Accountability In Public Education →

Reporter's Notebook

New Federal Guidelines Strive To End Racial Inequality In Schools

Students of color are more likely to be suspended from school, have less access to rigorous classes, and taught by less experienced teachers even as more students of color are enrolled in public schools than white students across the nation.

Now, the Obama administration is addressing the problem head on.

Read more of New Federal Guidelines Strive To End Racial Inequality In Schools →

Reporter's Notebook

African-American Girls Face Obstacles In Our Schools

African-American girls are more likely to face harsh punishment, suspension, receive poor grades or be held back a grade than other girls their age.

In fact, African-American girls are faring worse than the national average for girls on a number of academic measures, according to a new report released by the National Women’s Law Center and the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund.

Read more of African-American Girls Face Obstacles In Our Schools →