Superintendent openings harder to fill as job demands more
Boston is engaged in an intensive and highly publicized search for its next superintendent this year, but it is far from the only Massachusetts school district looking for a new leader — a task that education specialists say is becoming increasingly difficult.
Searches are on in several communities across the Commonwealth from Boston to Belchertown, but the pool of applicants is relatively small. This spring, Belchertown and Northampton extended offers to the same man for their superintendencies, and Belchertown had to appoint an interim superintendent after its first choice took the Northampton position.
In Boston, the school committee is looking for someone who "possesses strong communication, financial, interpersonal and management skills, as well as a clear vision for BPS’ students, families, and community,” according to a leadership profile drafted by a consulting firm commissioned to help with the search.
Issues like the achievement gap, diversity, funding, testing, and outdated facilities are atop the list of mandates for Boston’s next superintendent.
Finding a leader who has all of these skills and shares each of these priorities is a daunting job, state education specialists said.
“We’re finding it more and more challenging to get high quality candidates,” said Tom Scott, executive director of the Massachusetts Association of School Superintendents. “The pool has dwindled significantly.”
Of the nearly 300 superintendencies in Massachusetts, 50 positions were open in the last several months, according to Glenn Koocher, director of the Massachusetts Association of School Committees. When Koocher helped with his first superintendent search in Cambridge about 40 years ago, he said, more than 120 people applied, including 20 first-tier candidates. Now, he said, districts are happy to see between six and eight first-tier applicants.
In many ways, the formidable challenge of the $130,000-a-year position both creates the openings and makes them harder to fill. Current superintendents get burned out, and there are fewer and fewer people either qualified or willing to step up to replace them.
Scott and Koocher said successful candidates must first be able to collaborate — with students, parents, staff, and politicians. They should be an active and welcoming force in the community. They must know how to manage a budget. They should know a little bit of law to understand regulations and educational standards.
They must be an educator with knowledge of how classrooms work. They need to understand current technology and its roles in lesson plans and testing. They need to be cognizant of the health and emotional welfare of children.
Scott refers to the superintendency as a “day and night job.”
“It’s a constant drain on your psyche,” he said.
Koocher said superintendents’ roles have expanded as state and federal programs like No Child Left Behind have emerged in recent decades, bringing more regulations, reporting requirements, and educational directives. At the same time, people increasingly criticize education leaders for failing to meet these new standards.
“Accountability has changed the nature of the job so increasingly everything is data-driven,” Scott said. “So you’ve got to show evidence for virtually all of your decisions. You've got to show evidence your decisions are showing results, data-driven results.”
Add early retirement into the mix — in Massachusetts, Koocher said, public educators who worked their entire careers in the state can generally retire at age 57 for up to 80 percent of their salary — and it’s hard to keep superintendents in place for more than a handful of years.
“Why do I want to go back to a job where the stress is enormous and we’re constantly under attack?” Koocher said.
Superintendents additionally face unique challenges specific to their individual districts.
In Winchester, for example, the school committee is looking for a candidate who can stretch a budget and stay committed to the goal of keeping class sizes small, said Committee Chair Chris Nixon. They hope to hire someone by January of next year.
The challenge, Nixon said, is a 25 percent increase in enrollment from 3,400 students in the 2002-03 school year to more than 4,300 at the end of 2012-13.
“Our challenges at budget season have been simply keeping pace with the goals,” he said.
Though the next superintendent in a comparatively wealthy suburb like Winchester will not deal with the challenge of turnaround schools like the next administrator in Boston, he or she will face the additional stress of maintaining high levels of achievement, Koocher said.
“If you’re in a wealthy community, you’re under a lot of pressure to win the World Series again next year,” he said.
Despite the varied demands, there are still universal skills all superintendent candidates must possess, according to outgoing school leaders in Massachusetts. Chief among them are communication and multitasking.
Susan Hitchcock, in her last year at the helm of Millbury Public Schools, said a superintendent must be multidimensional and have experience in district-wide administration.
“You can no longer be successful in this position if you’re just, for example, coming from the business field or having just been a principal even,” she said.
A thick skin would help, too, said Tony Pierantozzi, the superintendent in Somerville who plans to retire at the end of next school year.
“It’s kind of like baseball — everyone went to school so everyone has an opinion on everything,” he said.