Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Last Bell

Last Bell: Proposal for a New High School in Mattapan, Poetry and the Common Core, Most Seniors Not Ready for College Math and Reading, AP Program Offers Lessons for the Common Core

Open Media Boston argues in an editorial that the mayor's office should consider a city councilor's proposal to build a new high school in Mattapan.

Councilor Charles Yancey, according to Open Media Boston, recently issued a bulletin about a proposed $120 million public high school at the former site of the Boston State Hospital in Mattapan. He first tried to get a new school on that spot in 2000 when he secured a $57 million loan order, the website reports.

"Boston public school students deserve a new high school campus that's at least as good as the two dozen new suburban high schools that have been built in surrounding communities since the original 2000 loan order," Open Media Boston writes.

—

A think tank in Boston is arguing that schools will not spend enough time teaching poetry under the Common Core, The Boston Globe reports.

According to The Globe, the conservative Pioneer Institute issued a report last month about the use of poetry in classrooms.

Though Department of Elementary and Secondary Education Commissioner Mitchell Chester told The Globe poetry would always be a part of elementary curriculum in Massachusetts, the Pioneer Institute remained unconvinced.

The Pioneer report argues that reading poetry only to pull it apart and analyze it misses the beauty and the joy of language. “Poetry for poetry’s sake befits a fully mature human being, who is infinitely more than a worker or a voter,” states the report, coauthored by Anthony Esolen, Jamie Highfill, and Sandra Stotsky.

—

Education Week reports national analysts found fewer than 40 percent of high school seniors are ready for college courses in math and reading.

The finding comes from the National Assessment Governing Board, which looked at testing data and determined minimum college preparedness scores, according to Education Week.

Essentially, what NAGB did was set a cut score for the level of achievement a student must reach to be considered academically prepared for college. In math, a student must score at least 163 (on a 0-to-300 scale) to be considered prepared for college; for reading they must score 302 (on a 0-to-500 scale).

In 2013, the average scores for the nation were 153 in math and 288 in reading.

According to Education Week, NAGB determined that 39 percent of seniors are ready for basic math courses and 38 percent are ready for basic reading courses in college.

—

The Advanced Placement program offers a good example of how the Common Core can succeed, a fellow and an analyst from the Center for American Progress write in Real Clear Education.

Ulrich Boser and Max Marchitello acknowledge the controversy around the Common Core, but they point to the growth of the decades-old AP program as evidence that new standards can improve education in the United States.

But given the success of the AP program, the controversy around the Common Core standards seems misplaced. After all, the AP program suggests that high standards and robust exams are a successful reform approach. What's more, both the AP program and the Common Core originate from a realization among educators that far more needs to be done to raise expectations for students. In short, critics should look to the AP program as a model of what the Common Core can become — a successful education reform that improves teaching and raises student expectations.