Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

A good school is ...

New School Choice Framework Expands What 'Quality' Can Mean

A new school quality framework adopted by Boston School Committee will give a more thorough understanding of a school's quality.  (Charles Rex Arbogast/AP)
A new school quality framework adopted by Boston School Committee will give a more thorough understanding of a school's quality. (Charles Rex Arbogast/AP)

Choosing a school to send a student to can be a tough decision for families: How close is the school to my house? How do the academics rate? What kind of support will my student receive? What extracurriculars are there? What are people saying about the school?

On Wednesday night, the Boston School Committee voted to adopt a new policy that will incorporate parent and student feedback, alongside test scores, into the school ratings families use when enrolling their children in Boston schools.

The policy is set to begin in the 2016-2017 school year.

"Everyone wants a quality school," School Committee Chairman Michael O'Neill said. "But everyone has a different definition of quality."

Three-quarters of a school's rating will be derived from scores on the MCAS exam. The remaining quarter will come from feedback on a number of standards: teaching and learning, leadership and collaboration, student access and opportunities and family, community and culture.

Under current policy, families can choose from a customized list of schools using a formula that tries to balance proximity with school quality. The list includes every school within a one-mile radius of a family's home and rates them based on test scores.

"The only real objective measure of quality that we've had to work with are MCAS scores -- scores on the annual assessment test," Hardin Colman, a school committee member and former co-chair of the External Advisory Committee on School Choice, said in an interview Thursday.

But not every grade takes those tests.

"You would be making a decision for your kindergartner based on the performance of last year's third graders in Math and English Arts," Colman said.

While every family has at least two of the highest-scoring schools and at least four schools that are in the top half of the district's MCAS performance on their customized list, community members made it clear that they wanted a more comprehensive way to examine a school's character.

"Our task force worked to create our own measurement of quality of schools that is more complex and more appropriate than the single state measures we've been using," Colman said.

Alongside the new standards, the framework will also measure a school by student progress, achievement gaps and will take the demographic population of the school into account. The annual School Climate Survey given to students and parents in the spring will be taken into account in rating the school, among other feedback.

Based on the new metric, schools will be divided into four "School Quality Tiers." On families' customized school choice lists, there will still be at least two schools in the top tier and four in the top half.