Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

New Independent Charter Schools Unlikely This Year

Sixth grade students, from left, Shakerrah Baptiste, 12, Shamari Banks, 11, Kyron Brown, 11, and Brielle Walker-James 12, raise their hands during a lesson on the myth of Narcissus during class at the Brooke Roslindale Charter School in Boston on Oct. 26, 2012. (Josh Reynolds/AP)
Sixth grade students, from left, Shakerrah Baptiste, 12, Shamari Banks, 11, Kyron Brown, 11, and Brielle Walker-James 12, raise their hands during a lesson on the myth of Narcissus during class at the Brooke Roslindale Charter School in Boston on Oct. 26, 2012. (Josh Reynolds/AP)

Update on October 17, 2014: Charter School Applicants Seek State Waiver

The groups seeking to open charter schools in Brockton and Fitchburg have requested the state education commission reverse their ruling that stopped their applications from moving forward.

The schools were told they could not proceed in the application process because of a state law that requires school districts that apply for independent charter funding to be in the lowest 10th percentile of MCAS scores in the state.

Our original post continues:

Massachusetts probably won't approve any new independently run charter schools this year.

Two new charter school applications, in Brockton and Fitchburg, were halted last week after state officials uncovered a procedural error that allowed the schools to advance in the approval process, the Boston Globe reported.

Independent charter schools operate independently of local school systems, with looser state regulations. They must be approved by the state's Department of Elementary and Secondary Education.

From the Globe:

In blocking the two current proposals, the state cited a provision in a 2010 education reform law that restricts where charter schools can open. The provision requires that at least two proposals in any given year be located in a district with MCAS performance in the bottom 10 percent in the state. Both Brockton and Fitchburg are above that threshold.

It was the first time the provision has halted the approval process. In past years, the state entertained many proposals for such low-performing districts as Boston.

But Boston, where many charter school operators want to locate, reached its state-imposed cap on charter enrollment two years ago, and the number of statewide finalists last year slipped to six. Only two of those were ultimately approved.

Jeff Wulfson, a state deputy education commissioner, said the error in the Brockton and Fitchburg proposals occurred because the charter school office was vetting the caliber of the applications while another office was simultaneously generating the list of districts in the bottom 10 percent. It was only after the charter school office selected the finalists that staff members realized they forgot to check the updated MCAS rankings.

However, Wulfson added, the applicants have been offered the opportunity to relocate their charter schools to a qualifying district.

The first charter schools opened in the state 20 years ago. This may be the first time in 15 years that no new independent charters will be approved. It comes just months after the Massachusetts state Senate rejected legislation that would have expanded the number of students that could be served by charter schools in poorly performing school districts.

Both moves are a blow to charter school advocates.

Omari Walker, president of the Resiliency Foundation, a nonprofit that is developing the New Heights Charter School in Brockton, told the Globe: "It's disappointing to everyone that a technicality like this is stopping momentum and taking away a school that can do so much. We feel this is prohibiting students from an opportunity in life they would not otherwise get."

Other charter school proponents see the move as signalling the need for a different type of charter school.

"Districts should take it as an opportunity to pursue creating similar [charter] schools within their districts that have similar types of autonomy," Dan French, executive director of the Center for Collaborative Education, said in an interview Tuesday.

The state is continuing to review charters in Boston, Salem and Springfield for "in-district charters" -- charter schools that would operate in partnership with those school systems.