Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

Board Of Education Places The State's First Virtual School On Probation

State officials are considering whether or not to place the Greenfield Commonwealth Virtual School, Massachusett's first virtual school, on probation. (Mary Ann Chastain/AP)
State officials placed the Greenfield Commonwealth Virtual School, Massachusetts's first virtual school, on probation. (Mary Ann Chastain/AP)

Educators around Massachusetts are closely monitoring the state's exploration of virtual schools, which offer nearly all instruction online.

Now, due to low academic achievement and a failure to meet state curriculum standards, state education officials have unanimously approved probation for the Greenfield Commonwealth Virtual School, Massachusetts' first virtual school.

Update at 2:20 p.m. ET: Board Of Education Places School On Probation

We've updated the top of this post and headline to reflect the results of the Board of Education's Tuesday meeting, where the Massachusetts Board of Elementary and Secondary Education unanimously approved probation for the Greenfield and a Boston charter school, Boston Green Academy.

Both schools will have at least a year to demonstrate academic improvement, the Boston Globe reports in a new story.

The Greenfield's executive director did not immediately respond to Learning Lab's requests for comment on the ruling.

Our original post continues below:

In 2012, students scored far below other students on standardized tests, and half quit during the academic year or did not return the next year, according to an investigation by the New England Center For Investigative Reporting.

The Globe reported additional concerns with the private company the Greenfield contracts to hire and evaluate teachers.

Attending the virtual school is free for families; the $6,625 in annual tuition is covered by their local school system. Boston, for instance, is paying out more than $218,000 a year, and Springfield pays $331,000.

How much of that money is going into the pockets of the publicly traded company — Virginia-based K12 Inc. — remains unclear. The Greenfield virtual school refused to say, and K12 referred all comments to the school.

The school has 10.5 employees, mostly administrators, and is operating on a $5.8 million budget this year. A program administrator is provided by K12 as well as teachers and many other services. The state review found that the quality of instruction at the school “falls far below” standards, faulting teachers for failing to check for student understanding during lessons and not requiring students to think critically.

The Greenfield is one of two virtual schools in the state. The other, TEC Connections Academy, opened this fall and has hoped to take lessons from the Greenfield's mistakes.