Boston's 'School Choice Season' Starts Today

Today marks the beginning of "school choice season" in Boston Public Schools.
From now until registration opens in January, families may visit schools to meet principals and teachers and get an inside glimpse of how individual schools operate.
"When families visit schools and explore options, their choice list always ends up being longer rather than shorter," said Denise Snyder, Director of Welcome Services for Boston Public Schools. "We really want them to make informed choices and to come in with several schools that they are interested in."
All kindergarten through 8th grade schools in Boston will be open for scheduled tours and for November 15th's "Showcase In Our Schools."
During school visits, families can see a school's curriculum and resources, take a look at student achievement and access to art or music programs, inquire about counseling and health services, and learn about dress codes and school philosophy.
Any of which can individually affect how a family decides what makes a good school.
However, there is one important question that must be answered first: which schools can my child even attend?
Home-Based School Choice
When a family wants to register a child for school in Boston, every family receives a customized list of schools to choose from based on where a family lives.
A family's list includes every school located within a one-mile radius of a family’s home. The list includes at least two top performing BPS schools and at least four schools that are in the top half of district performance.
Schools are broken into four tiers based on their MCAS scores. Schools with the top 25 percent of MCAS scores are in Tier I, schools with scores in the middle 26-50 percent are in Tier II, schools with scores in the middle 51-75 percent are in Tier III, and the remaining schools are in Tier IV.
Every family's list will have at least two schools in Tier I and four schools in Tier II.
If the schools within a one-mile radius do not meet these qualifications, BPS will include the nearest high performing schools on a family’s list.
Families then submit their choices in preference order to BPS who assigns students by a computerized lottery. Students with siblings already attending a school are given priority.
BPS has a new online tool that allows families to input their home address and they are given a list of schools, for which they may apply.
Confused about how this works?
"There certainly was a little bit of confusion among families that didn't quite know what 'home-based' meant," Snyder said about last year's school choice process. "For some they thought that meant that they would automatically go to a school close to home. For others, they didn't even know there was a home-base."
Let's use apples to simplify what's happening in BPS's Home-Based School Choice:
Say, there's a an apple orchard. Every fall, when its time to pick apples, people need to decide which tree they will eat from. They get to decide on one tree and only one tree. And whatever tree they choose, they must eat from year after year.
The only problem is, the trees are not all the same. There are trees with brown leaves that have been neglected and always produce apples with rotten parts, trees with yellow leaves that once were neglected but are now being given care and have started producing apples that are getting tastier every season, and a few trees with green leaves that always produce crisp and tasty apples.
When it comes time to choose a tree to eat from, everyone wants a bite of a good apple from a green tree. But there aren't enough good apples to go around.
So the farmer in charge of the orchard will let people choose where to eat from depending on where in the orchard they are located: every tree in a 25-foot radius is fair game to choose.
This is good news for the people located in an area with a lot of green trees. But for the people that find themselves surrounded by brown trees, this isn't so hot.
So the farmer makes another promise: Every tree in a 25-foot radius is fair game to choose to eat from and everyone will have the option to choose from at least two green trees and at least four yellow or green trees. If there are no yellow or green trees in in the 25-foot radius, the closest yellow and green trees will be made available.
So for the people surrounded by brown trees, they still have the option of choosing from the other trees. They may just be a little farther away.
The farmer then assigns people which tree they may eat from based on their desires, how many more people the tree can handle, and if they have family at the tree already.
The same is true for BPS and assigning schools. Every family is guaranteed schools that are in the top half of BPS schools, based on test performance. If none are located nearby, the closest high performing schools will be included as an option for which they may enter a lottery to attend.
Join the conversation. Let us know what you think makes a good school. Leave a comment below or send us an email and we'll feature it in our "A Good School Is..." series.