Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

Questionable Spending From Boston School Fund

An investigation by a city watchdog agency, the Boston Finance Commission, is questioning the validity of Boston school officials' practice of funneling taxpayer money into the accounts of a nonprofit foundation, The Boston Globe reports.

Revenue generated from renting out school facilities, selling off old equipment, and leasing school buses was deposited into the accounts of the Boston Educational Development Foundation, instead of being put to use to help run schools.

From the Globe:

Once the money was in the foundation accounts, there were few restrictions, allowing the money to be spent on, for example, dinner tabs at Legal Sea Foods restaurants and the Park Plaza. The investigation examined some but not all of the foundation’s numerous accounts going as far back as 2008 and through 2012. The findings will be released Tuesday.

“The citizens of Boston entrust agents of the city to manage their resources honestly and prudently,” Matthew Cahill, the Boston Finance Commission’s executive director, said in a letter to Mayor Martin J. Walsh that was provided to the Globe. “This investigation has raised serious concerns regarding how taxpayer assets have been managed.”

In an interview, Cahill, whose group is an independent watchdog agency established by the Legislature, said the movement of public dollars into the foundation and the subsequent spending was not necessarily illegal, but “it’s a questionable practice.”

He called for an independent audit of all spending at the foundation. As of June 2013, the foundation had $13.4 million in funds and assets, according to its most recent federal tax form posted on the website of the state attorney general’s office.

The report shows that beyond food tabs, the foundation served as a personal piggy bank for holiday parties, first-class plane tickets and moving expenses for a departing employee.

One of the foundation accounts used for restaurant and catering expenses received $264,000 by renting out school buses between 2009 and 2012. The commission said this money should be used to lighten the burden of transportation costs, which constitutes roughly 10 percent of Boston's school budget.

This report comes on the heels of school officials ending district-provided school buses for most eight-graders -- in a move officials said was necessary to cut costs.

The Globe's highlights from the investigation include:

  • $13,776 in moving expenses to the school system’s chief academic officer in May 2009 after she resigned and returned to California. Boston school officials said former superintendent Carol R. Johnson authorized the expense.

 

  • $1,572 for airfare and two nights of lodging for a job applicant over a weekend in August 2012 at the W hotel, at $266 per night. School officials said the applicant needed to interview on the weekend because she could not miss work.

 

  • $1,100 for a first-class plane ticket for former New York City schools chancellor Rudolph Crew in September 2011. Crew flew from California to Boston to meet with school officials, even though the Finance Commission had rejected a contract that would have paid him $1,500 a day. School officials said Crew did not work under the contract while in Boston.

 

  • $2,000 for “Creative Palate by Damian” to cater a holiday party in December 2011. School officials declined to comment on the expenditure but said in general catering is reserved for staff training and other all-day activities.

The City of Boston is currently engaging in a full audit of the entire school system and its resources, including the funds questioned in this report, Interim Superintendent John McDonough said in a statement.

"Our expectation," McDonough continued in the statement, "is that these resources must always be used to help students and the school system improve in some specific way."