Charting The Future Of The Dearborn School

Determining that the Dearborn Middle School in Roxbury has not exhibited the type of rapid academic progress needed, Boston Public Schools (BPS) has chosen nonprofit BPE, formerly known as the Boston Plan for Excellence, to run the school as an outside partner.
In recent years the Dearborn School, which currently serves about 300 students, has consistently ranked among the district's lowest achieving and least improving schools.
The Dearborn partnership was green-lighted last week to avoid having the school potentially taken over by the state. Yet, outside operators have failed to raise test scores or turn around student performance at other schools that enacted partnerships last fall.
This happens as Boston school officials move forward with plans to raze the building currently housing the Dearborn and transform the middle school into the Dearborn STEM Academy, a $71 million facility for grades six through 12 with state-of-the-art science and engineering labs.
Here's what you need to know about BPE -- and what the future of the Dearborn could look like.
Who is BPE?
BPE is a nonprofit organization focused on education that currently operates a handful of programs including a teacher training residency program, a literacy-focused partnership with Americorps and an elementary charter school in Roxbury.
"We're increasingly trying to support building great schools," said Jesse Solomon, executive director of BPE.
This is not the first time that BPE has had their eye on the Dearborn School. Earlier this year BPE was approached by the interim superintendent and asked to take over the Dearborn as an in-district charter school.
In September the charter proposal was stopped after coming under intense fire by Dearborn supporters who said that proposal was developed without their input.
Now, as a public school, BPE has again been named to run the Dearborn.

What does BPE say it needs for a successful turnaround?
In a proposal submitted to BPS outlining their plan for the school, BPE writes that it requires specific "conditions and decision-making authority" in order to be successful.
The first is a five-year contract. The standard time-frame for a turnaround process is a three-year partnership.
Solomon says it is important to focus on long-term investments and three years is not long enough.
"This is incredibly hard work," Solomon said. "There are not too many examples of good high school turnarounds."
If any extension beyond three years or renewal is to occur, however, Boston school officials say it would have to be approved at the three-year mark.
Although Dearborn will still be considered a district school, BPE writes that it would like "Horace Mann-like autonomies." Horace Mann schools are semi-autonomous charter schools that work outside of district guidelines for staffing, hiring practices, calendar, working conditions and curriculum.
This autonomy would essentially give BPE many of the freedoms of operating the school as an in-district charter, minus the name. And BPS, it seems, is agreeing to that.
"The Dearborn will be funded the same way as every other BPS school is funded -- through student-weighted funding, but BPE will have a lot of ability to spend those resources on staffing, on partnerships, on time in ways that are different than BPS would have done it," said Lee McGuire, chief communications officer for BPS.
BPE and BPS will select a school leader together, but beyond that BPE will have much of the flexibility of an in-district charter school as it works to turn around performance at the Roxbury school.
"It's essentially the same set of conditions that a Horace Mann charter would have or a Level 4 turnaround school has -- BPE has the flexibility to make those decisions on their own," McGuire said.
Which students will attend the Dearborn School?
Although given charter-like autonomy, the main point of contention that helped kill this summer's initial charter proposal -- district-wide access -- will not be present.
Unlike charters, which can enroll students from across the district, the Dearborn will continue to participate in the home-based school choice program that allows only students living nearby to apply for open seats at the soon-to-be-remodeled school.
Rev. Liz Walker of Roxbury Presbyterian Church is among a number of vocal community members who has worked to preserve community access to the school.
"We're demanding a place in the process," said Walker. "My goal is to keep my promise to the neighborhood children that they would have access to the school and a STEM education."
Dearborn also currently receives students from five feeder schools: Ellis Elementary, Mason Elementary, Perkins Elementary, Tynan Elementary and Winthrop Elementary. Students from these five feeder schools are guaranteed assignments at Dearborn.
Remaining seats are available for students applying through the home-based school choice plan.

BPE operates other schools. Could this impact Dearborn?
BPE is the co-founder and operator of the nearby Dudley Street Neighborhood Charter School (DCNS), that, for now, serves students from pre-kindergarten up to second grade.
Opened in 2012, the school is adding a grade each year until it services students through fifth grade. As part of their plan, BPE would like to turn DSNCS into a future feeder for Dearborn.
"It's the idea that your child knows that they have a seat in a school they want all the way through," said Solomon.
As a charter school, DSNCS is open to the entire district. If approved as a feeder school for Dearborn, it could create a small, citywide gateway to the future STEM Academy.
McGuire says this will not be part of a turnaround plan for Dearborn that BPS will approve. At least, not immediately.
"It would make some sense to have a conversation about bridging the Dudley Street Neighborhood Charter School and the Dearborn at some point in the future" McGuire said. "But it would require School Committee action to do so."
WBUR’s Delores Handy contributed to this report.
- Related: Walsh Halts Proposal To Convert Boston’s Dearborn School Into A Charter