Commission To Review Whether Mass. School Districts Get Enough Funding

Could we be working with an outdated, ineffective and, ultimately, wrong method of calculating the amount of money school districts need?
Some Massachusetts policy analysts think so. Now, the state Legislature has a group working to officially answer that question.
The Foundation Budget Review Commission, created by the Massachusetts Legislature last year, will examine the school finance law that determines how much money Massachusetts' local and regional school districts need in order to provide students with an adequate education.
"The foundation budget is the core funding mechanism for operating K-12 schools," said Deputy Commissioner Jeff Wulson of the Department of Elementary and Secondary Education. "There's a general consensus in the field that a revisiting of the foundation budget is well overdue."
The commission is due to issue a report in June with recommendations to update and improve the law.
Foundation Budget Spending
Under specific scrutiny is how the state's foundation spending standard is calculated.
A district's foundation budget is the base level of per-pupil funding that each district needs to provide an adequate education, according to the state. The state then makes up any gap between that number and how much a district ought to be able to fund from local taxes, through a process called Chapter 70 funding.
"The purpose for the foundation program is to ensure every district has a minimum level of resources," said Wulson. "We need to be able to say with that minimum level of resources they can provide an adequate education."
This funding, notably, is a starting-point, not a ceiling. Districts can raise money locally through methods such as private grants, foundations and nonprofits to supplement their foundation budgets.
Underfunding Has 'Real, On The Ground Consequences'
Currently, major gaps are present between what the foundation budget says districts need and what districts are actually spending.
A report by MassBudget gathered data from the state's 328 operating districts and analyzed key trends found across each.
The study found that most districts hire far fewer regular education teachers than the foundation budget sets as the adequate number. The education funding formula does not reflect increased health insurance and special education costs, forcing most districts to compensate with funds that would have supported hiring regular education teachers.
The foundation budget estimate of statewide district spending on special education and health insurance falls short by over $2 billion.
Luc Schuster, deputy director of MassBudget and author of that study, is a non-voting advisory member of the Foundation Budget Review Commission.
"The consequence of that in the classroom is that districts are spending well below the foundation budget assumption on regular education teachers," said Schuster. "Many schools in the commonwealth have larger class sizes than were intended originally, teachers are having fewer prep periods to prepare and collaborate with each other between classes. There have been real on-the-ground consequences."
Districts in low-income, urbanized centers have absorbed the largest impacts of this disparity.
As these districts shift funds to cover rising health care and special education costs, the districts spend on average only two-thirds of the amount deemed necessary for regular education teachers.
No Consistent Reviews
The Education Reform Act, which established the formula for calculating a district's foundation budget and corresponding state aid, was passed in 1993. It mandates that the governor appoints a foundation budget review commission every three years to review the way in which foundation budgets are calculated.
With a triennial review, the method for determining the amount of money districts need would not remain fixed to 1993 -- a time when less than a quarter of American households had computer access, the use of iPads in classrooms was a far-off dream, and Massachusetts' standardized MCAS assessments were just being implemented.
Despite this stipulation in the law, consistent reviews of district funding have not happened. It's been over 10 years since the last formal review commission issued a report.
"The original law did anticipate [reviews would happen every three years]. It was done a couple of times and kind of fell by the wayside in part because the state started going through some difficult economic times," said Wulson.
Meaning, aside from an annual adjustment for inflation, the very process to determine how much money districts need has not been adjusted for subsequent classroom technologies, wraparound services, expanded learning time, rising costs of health insurance for teachers or increasing early education programs.
Looking To The Future, Redefining Student Needs
"This is really the first opportunity in more than a decade for the Legislature to lead a broad public conversation around what we want to provide in our public schools in Massachusetts," said Schuster.
He is enthusiastic that it could provide an occasion to reevaluate the necessary components of a good Massachusetts education.
"This commission is an opportunity to consider redefining what we think of as the core education program that we are providing for kids today," said Schuster. "Is the foundation budget we designed even the full educational program we want to be delivering today in the 21st century?"