Report: Schools, Partners Must Do More To Address External Barriers To Academic Success

Out-of-school factors account for two-thirds of the achievement gap between low-income students and their peers, with childhood poverty as the single largest factor to consider, a new report on Massachusetts education details.
The annual Condition of Education in the Commonwealth report released Thursday from the Rennie Center for Education Research & Policy, a Boston-based research non-profit, says that it is time for state and local communities to devote more attention to developing effective student support models that address student needs outside of the school building.
"This has been a challenge for our educational system that has been emerging for the past two decades," said Chad d'Entremont Executive Director of the Rennie Center for Education Research & Policy and co-author of the report. "In particular high-needs students, those in poverty, continue to struggle."
The report -- which analyzes student data, zeroes in on where outcomes lag and identifies existing practices that can address those areas -- also finds that Massachusetts students can benefit from expanded access to preschool programs and high school curricula that blend with credit-bearing college courses.
Developing A Statewide, Holistic Approach To Student Support
Today, 16 percent of Massachusetts children live below the poverty line. In cities, that rate is almost doubled -- 31 percent of children in urban communities live in poverty, according to the Kids Count data center.
Factors that influence children's academic success extend far beyond the reach of public schools, but there is a growing consensus that schools and their partners must do more to address non-academic barriers to academic success.
"Schools have always tried to address these needs, they just can't do it all," said Mary Walsh, Executive Director of City Connects and the Daniel Kearns Professor of Urban Education and Innovative Leadership at the Lynch School of Education at Boston College. "Particularly for districts where the population is largely living in poverty, the schools are not able to provide for all the needs of the children."
Walsh's organization, City Connects, employs a full-time school counselor or social worker as a site coordinator in each of the 49 Massachusetts schools they work with. School teams review and triage the needs of all students by risk and identify appropriate support services.
"Each child has a customized plan that supports their strengths and addresses their needs," said Walsh.
Customized student support plans can include access to after-school programs, health and wellness classes, mentoring, mental health counseling, and violence intervention. Plans may be adjusted as students' needs change.
Effective student support programs, the report says, focus on school attendance, work in collaboration with community partners and address academic, social-emotional, health, and family-related concerns.
"It's hard work making sure that multiple organizations and programs are all on the same page working to support students," said d'Entremont. Although there are many state agencies and partners working with districts to address these needs, districts and schools can struggle to strategically coordinate contributions from partners.
Groups like City Connects evaluate students and then act as middle-men to connect schools, families and support services.
According to the report, districts can help students by implementing more holistic assessments that identify and diagnose student needs and by mapping out the capacity of local agencies.
Expanding Early Childhood Programming
Low-income children who attend quality early education programs are 30 percent more likely to graduate from high school and more than twice as likely to attend college, the report says.
The report notes expanding early childhood programming as a priority action for statewide action. This comes just on the heels of new proposed legislation to implement universal preschool in the state.
However, the report notes, one of the inherent challenges to Massachusetts' present early childhood system is in its diversity. Preschool may be accessed from public schools, community-based nonprofits, for-profit centers, and independent caregivers.
"One of the challenges that's existed in the early educational space is that for many years, it's existed as a non-system," said d'Entremont. "So, there are individual programs that do great work with the children they serve. But knowing how programs are doing in terms of quality across the board, how students have access to them, having consistent systems for funding, it's not there."
Individual programs rely on different sources of funding and function largely in isolation, which can contribute to inequities in program quality and staff compensation. Currently, only 30 percent of early and out-of-school educators have a bachelor's degree or higher.
The report recommends harnessing the state's diverse prekindergarten options to analyze best practices and subsequently develop a community-based, mixed-provider approach to prekindergarten. Publicly funded programs, the report says, can then have a uniform set of standards to which they can be held accountable.

Blending High School and College Coursework
Eighty-five percent of Massachusetts students graduate from high school in four years. However, less than one-third of students who begin their high school career in Massachusetts public schools go on to complete a diploma and college degree within six years of high school.
The momentum that students may need to finish college could begin in high school.
"There are real opportunities for students to earn college credit at the same time they're involved in high school," said Daniel Asquino, President of Mount Wachusett Community College (MWCC).
The report notes that Massachusetts is home to a number of "early college" partnerships between school districts and post-secondary institutions that blend a high school curriculum with credit-bearing college courses. Students may earn up to two years of college credits along with a high school diploma.
Mount Wachusett Community College is a program member of the Gateway to College National Network. High school students with a GPA of 3.0 and above from 23 districts can use school choice to enroll in MWCC's Pathways Early College Innovation School to enhance their academics.
Jillian Johnson enrolled in the program as a high school junior to get a head-start on her goal of becoming an orthodontist. She simultaneously earned her high school diploma and an associate degree in Liberal Arts and Sciences.
MWCC's Gateway to College program targets students on the other end of the academic spectrum.
"High school students who are at risk of dropping out or have already dropped out -- we bring them back," said Asquino. "They take courses here in order to complete their high school diploma and at the same time they gain college credit."
National studies, the report says, indicate that students enrolled in such programs are significantly more likely than their peers to graduate from high school, enroll in college, and earn a degree.
In the 2011-2012 school year, roughly three percent of all high school juniors and seniors were enrolled in both public high school and a public higher education institution.
The reports release, d'Entremont says, can be an occasion to renew efforts to better Massachusetts education.
"We're in a position to act," said d'Entremont. "There's a sense of urgency around this work."