Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

Guest Column: 'Keep A Clear Head About The School Deficit'

0205_Liam-Kerr

At Wednesday night's Boston School Committee meeting, Interim Superintendent John McDonough proposed to close a handful of Boston schools, citing a deficit of $42 million to $52 million in the Boston Public Schools budget.

Liam Kerr is the Executive Director of the political advocacy group Democrats for Education Reform. He says when people wonder "where did the money go?" they should keep a few things in mind.

 
Silly season is about to start here in Boston when it comes to public school finances.

The annual municipal budget process puts our investment priorities under an annual review, providing an ideal opportunity for special interests and aggrieved parties to make noise. This noise is loudest on the Boston Public Schools budget, and for good reason. Education counts for more than a third of the city budget, not to mention thousands of hopes, dreams, values, and paychecks.

The public discussion on the Boston Public Schools budget also contains a disproportionate amount of misinformation. And that confusion leads the public - and parents - to point fingers at the wrong leaders and ask the wrong questions.

The largest misconception is that the budget is being cut by politicians at City Hall and in the State House. While those are important financial roles for both, the general criticism is off base. Budgets, even when considering inflation, have been growing rapidly for a generation. From the first year of the Menino Administration to the first year of the Walsh Administration the budget for Boston Public Schools more than doubled, from less than $400 million to $1 billion. Accounting for inflation, there is an extra $350 million in the budget over twenty years. Meanwhile, the number of students in Boston Public Schools has dropped by roughly 10%, from 64,000 to 57,000.

This two decade look proves one comparison for the growing budget. Another comparison is looking at similar school districts in Massachusetts. Worcester Public Schools, for example, serves a student population with similar attributes but spends nearly $4,000 less per student. That averages out to just under $70,000 more per classroom of 17 students (the BPS average). There is an argument to be made the the pie should be larger, or that wealthy school districts should receive less state money. I’d be happy to make both arguments -- but simply claiming that public schools in Boston are victims of a sudden dearth of funding are simply untrue.

Another frequent mistaken claim is that certain politically contentious initiatives are driving this wedge between priorities, especially charter schools and assessments. Anti-testing advocates have a cable news style ability to tie testing to any and all maladies of public education. The current outrage du jour is that the new PARCC test, aligned with the Common Core State Standards, will be draining school budgets and cutting everything that tugs at heartstrings - arts, music, counselors, sports, smiles (ok, not smiles). That type of claim might fly on Glenn Beck’s chalkboard, but the PARCC test costs $30 per student.

Funding of public charter schools is more complex, but has taken on a similarly all-encompassing level of blame for what ails regular public schools and their budgets. As economists say, “If you torture the data long enough, it will confess.” And district school partisans have wrung out quite the confession: charter schools eat up most of state aid to Boston Public Schools. That is nominally true if you ignore the 8,000 Boston students in charter school classrooms that Boston Public Schools no longer have to educate (which would cost more than $110 million at the current per pupil average for BPS). You would also have to ignore the roughly $30 million in reimbursement funding from the state, a political compromise that pads the Boston Public Schools budget for students it no longer educates.

Finally, a more recent assertion is that new initiatives launched by the Walsh Administration are driving a budget crisis. Claiming that Walsh’s investments in early childhood, teacher quality, and expanded learning time unfairly “squeeze” the budget is an affront to any management philosophy. That’s what good managers do - invest in the priorities that can most help kids directly.

Priorities are the problem in the big picture. The macro view is forsaken in these annual budget battles. How did per pupil spending rise by 50% in real dollar terms during the past two decades? Where did it go?

If someone said we could increase the schools budget by half, we would be filled with visions of new school buildings, efficient transportation, the latest technology, more arts, music, sports, and tutors - all the things that advocates claim are cut for standardized tests or charters or misguided mayors and state legislators. And these are the things that voters meant when they told pollsters they wanted “major changes” to public schools during the mayoral race.

Which calls to mind the common refrain, “Show me your budget, and I’ll show you your values.” While more investment will be needed to change the current system, the total dollars spent at Boston Public Schools do show a city and state with values in the right place. When it comes time to ask why those dollars are not being spent well for kids, your current mayor and state legislators are not the place to go asking. Advocates should look back for blame, and think about the bigger picture when advocating for changes.