Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

Amid Concerns, Baker Says Chester Belongs 'In The Conversation' On PARCC

Mitchell Chester is the state commissioner of elementary and secondary education. (Peter Balonon-Rosen/WBUR)
Mitchell Chester is the state commissioner of elementary and secondary education. (Peter Balonon-Rosen/WBUR)

Gov. Charlie Baker said Tuesday he doesn't see a need for Education Commissioner Mitchell Chester to recuse himself from the decision on whether to replace the MCAS standardized test with the new PARCC exams.

Chester has been criticized for chairing the governing board of the group that developed the PARCC exams while leading the Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education. The latest call for him to step out of the decision came Tuesday from the Boston-based Pioneer Institute, a free-market-focused think tank.

Baker, however, said he doesn't think Chester's position "renders him unable to participate in the conversation," in part because the decision, expected this fall, would ultimately be up to the Board of Elementary and Secondary Education (BESE). Chester's role is to make a recommendation to the board.

"I was the only person in Massachusetts who testified against the move to Common Core back in 2010," Baker said Tuesday, according to State House News Service. "But I don't think my position or his is necessarily relevant here, because this is going to be a BESE decision."

Speaking at the International Space Station Research and Development Conference in Boston, Baker added, "Everybody knows what his background is and what his relation to this is, just as they know what my background is and my relationship to all this is, which is why I wanted the board to be the arbiter of this conversation."

Indeed, Chester's relationship to PARCC and the complex process that led to its development has been the subject of scrutiny for several years. The Peabody School Committee asked the state Ethics Committee to review the matter last year. The committee found no conflict because Chester had disclosed his ties to PARCC, but Peabody officials and others remain unconvinced.

In his unpaid role as chairman of the governing board for Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers (PARCC), a consortium of states developing a new student assessment system based on Common Core standards, Chester is in charge of designing, developing and implementing the PARCC exams that Massachusetts may soon adopt, and that more than half of the commonwealth's schools have already agreed to try out.

And that, says Dave McGeney of the Peabody School Committee, is in clear conflict with Chester's role as commissioner.

'It Defies Logic'

"You cannot be the person whose job it is to determine in all honesty and objectivity whether or not the PARCC test is going to be a better test than the MCAS test and be the person who is the chairman of the board of governors of that entity," McGeney said in a recent interview. "It defies logic. It flies in the face of reason. It wouldn’t happen in the private sector and it shouldn’t happen in the public sector."

Like McGeney, Greg Sullivan, research director at the Pioneer Institute, says that Chester's having filed a statement of disclosure doesn't necessarily mean that there is no conflict of interest.

"It only means that you’ve disclosed it and the parties who rank above you in the chain of command know about it and haven’t done anything to stop you from participating," said Sullivan, who is also a former state inspector general. "I think that it would be far better if Commissioner Chester were to recuse himself from the process. Otherwise, no matter which of the two assessment systems are selected, there will be a residual question as to whether it was influenced by virtue of the fact that Commissioner Chester was chair of the governing board of one side."

But Chester told Learning Lab in a recent interview that there is "absolutely not" a conflict of interest.

"I feel like I've been quite transparent with everybody about my role both for Massachusetts as well as my role and Massachusetts' role in developing the PARCC assessment," Chester said.

He underscored the fact that he will make a recommendation, not the final decision, on whether to switch from MCAS to PARCC. In addition, while he serves on the PARCC board, he currently has no role in PARCC Inc., the nonprofit that manages the consortium's business operations.

"My job is in fact to bring the best ideas and the best suggestions, the best policy recommendations to the commonwealth of Massachusetts," Chester said. "Ultimately, it is the state board of education that will make the decision whether or not we maintain our testing program or move to this next-generation assessment."

Paul Sagan, chair of the Board of Elementary and Secondary Education, agrees. In fact, he said in a recent interview, Chester serves on the PARCC governing board in order to represent Massachusetts' interests.

"The state — meaning the board, my predecessor, the governor and the secretary — wanted him to do that, to be there because it gives us a seat at the table and helps inform his recommendation that he will make to us later in the year," Sagan said. "We welcome him having that insight and being able to come to us with whatever conclusion he reaches. We don’t view it as a conflict, we view it as an asset."

PARCC's Grade: Mixed

The PARCC consortium started in 2010 with 25 states plus Washington, D.C., committed to developing, testing and implementing the exam. Since then, a majority of the member states have left the consortium, citing local backlash against PARCC, concerns over time devoted to testing, technology flaws, costs of the tests and issues with the Common Core standards themselves.

This school year, only 11 states plus the District of Columbia administered PARCC tests. In the past month, Arkansas announced it will no longer administer the tests and Ohio eliminated PARCC, shrinking the remaining states to nine plus D.C.

But Chester remains confident that PARCC is still a good option for Massachusetts to consider -- and said his leadership role has nothing to do with it.

"Our goal in building PARCC was in fact to develop a forward-looking assessment that took us to the next level of our MCAS assessment," Chester said. "Our MCAS assessment is a high-quality assessment. And it's probably state of the art for a 20th-century assessment. We're now in the 21st century."

MCAS was implemented in 1993.

"There's a lot of new technology that's been brought to bear, a lot of new ways of thinking about assessments, new ways of engaging students in a digital framework, in an assessment context that requires students to generate ideas, show their work, write their understanding," Chester said. "That's the goal that we've set for the assessment."

For the past two years, districts across the state have been doing "test runs" of the PARCC test to help determine its impact on students and teachers. Some Massachusetts educators have challenged the switch to PARCC, saying the tests decrease children's enthusiasm for learning, that test prep takes away from classroom time and that children may already be over tested.

Hadley Green contributed to this report.