As Congress Debates 'No Child Left Behind,' White House Finds Achievement Gaps

While many states and school districts show significant gains in student achievement, poor students and students of color are still given fewer opportunities to succeed.
That's the troubling news from "Giving Every Child a Fair Shot," a White House report released this week as Congress takes up potential revisions to the nation's most far-reaching education law. The report highlights national trends from the 2012-13 school year, the most recent year for which federal nationwide data is available.
Rewriting No Child Left Behind
This week, Congress began debating changes to the nation’s largest education law, the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA). The law, which sets accountability and funding for schools, was last updated over a decade ago as the controversial George W. Bush-era education law No Child Left Behind.
The House and Senate have developed separate bills that would each substantially revise the law, but in different ways. Both current versions, however, would transfer various powers from the federal government to states and districts and would mandate annual testing in grades 3 and 8 and once in high school. That's the current testing requirement in Massachusetts.
The House on Wednesday narrowly passed its version, with no support from Democrats and with 27 GOP members also joining the opposition. A more bipartisan version entered the Senate floor on Tuesday. The debate over the new law is expected to be lengthy and contentious, and the White House has stated its opposition to both the House and Senate bills.
In this week's report, the White House reported its own findings on the current state of public education, along with its own set of recommendations.
Good News ... For Some
According to the report, the national on-time public high school graduation rate is the highest ever, at 81 percent. The number of black and Latino students in college has increased by more than 1 million since 2008. And the nation's fourth- and eighth-graders' reading math scores improved over the previous year's.
But despite these successes, the report says, substantial challenges remain, especially in the poorest schools.
Students at the lowest-performing Title I schools — schools where over 40 percent of students live in poverty — face considerable achievement and opportunity gaps in a number of subjects.
In reading, only 36 percent of students in low-performing Title I schools have reached grade-level proficiency, compared to 67 percent in all other schools. In math, about two-thirds of these students do not meet grade-level standards — the mirror image of all other schools, where two-thirds are at or above grade level.
So it's no surprise that only about 40 percent of students in the lowest-performing schools graduate in four years — less than half the national rate. They're more likely to drop out, fall behind or be pushed out of school than to graduate on time.
In addition to the achievement gaps among schools, the report finds significant differences in achievement among groups of students. Students of color, as well as those who are poor, disabled or limited in English proficiency, are often given less support than others, the report finds.
From the report:
Often disadvantaged students in these schools are denied access to rigorous coursework, or are not held to the same high standards as other students. While 37% of high school students are black or Hispanic, they represent only 27% of students enrolled in at least one Advanced Placement (AP) course, and a mere 18% of students receiving a qualifying score of 3 or above on an AP exam. That is why it is critical that we identify schools that are failing any group of students and expect tailored actions in those schools to improve student outcomes.
To make real gains in student achievement, the report says, education laws must change in several ways. Specifically, it calls for raising standards in areas that relate to college and career readiness, increasing resources for adapting curriculum and instruction to individual students' needs, and changing assessments to focus on a student's progress over time, rather than taking "snapshots" with a few high-stakes tests.
Massachusetts: More Proficient, But More Gaps
Compared to other states, Massachusetts stacks up quite well in student proficiency overall. This is no surprise — in recent years Massachusetts has consistently ranked as a top state for public education.
Only about half of Massachusetts' eighth-grade students read at or above grade level — but that's the highest rate of reading proficiency in the nation. With 55 percent testing as proficient or higher, Massachusetts also leads the nation in math.
But Massachusetts also posts some of the nation's widest gaps in achievement.
The reading proficiency gap between Massachusetts' poorest, worst-performing schools and the rest of the state is the second highest in the U.S. Similarly, the gap in graduation rates is wider than most other states'.
In short, the commonwealth's students as a whole score better than in other states — but those in the worst-performing schools lag further behind their peers than do similar students elsewhere.