Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

Facing Districtwide Budget Cuts, One Boston School Pushes Back

Math teacher Grace Evans, left, meets with colleagues at Boston Community Leadership Academy to discuss budget cuts. The school faces an $870,000 budget shortfall next year. (Peter Balonon-Rosen/WBUR)
Math teacher Grace Evans, right, meets with colleagues at Boston Community Leadership Academy to discuss budget cuts. The school's governing board says they face an $870,000 budget shortfall next year. (Peter Balonon-Rosen/WBUR)
Facing Districtwide Budget Cuts, One Boston School Pushes Back

BOSTON -- Boston Community Leadership Academy may not have much of a leadership program next year.

Or a library. Or gym class. Or four of its current teachers.

If the Hyde Park high school’s proposed 2016-17 budget is approved, BCLA will start the school year with a projected shortfall of more than $870,000. That’s 19 percent of its current operating budget, and it would force cuts to just about every program that is not required by law.

"It's a position from history, it's a position from science, a position from math, the rest of the library, the leadership coordinator,” math teacher Grace Evans told about 25 fellow teachers at a meeting last week. “It's gym..." The list goes on.

"The Leadership Scholars, yeah. The 'LA' in 'BCLA' ... brooop," said Evans, making a cutting motion with her hands. She serves on the school’s 15-member governing board.

"In our view, as a board,” she said, “it's everything that makes us a school."

So when the board met the night before its proposed budget was due to the district, it made an unprecedented move.

"We as a board voted unanimously, saying, 'We reject this budget.' Meaning this is not a valid way to run a school," Evans told the teachers.

Evans said the board submitted the budget only because it was required to -- and it sent a letter of "no confidence" along with the numbers.

"The word we used at governing board was 'eviscerating,'" Evans said in an interview. "This eviscerates what we are as a school."

Lower Income, Higher Expenses And A Struggling District

So how did the BCLA’s proposed budget get cut by one-fifth in a single year? It comes down to two things: Boston Public Schools' new student-funding formula and BCLA's veteran staff.

Boston schools receive a set amount of money for each student they serve -- but the amount varies depending on the type of student.

High school students get one amount, younger students another. Schools also get extra money for certain groups of students -- like students living in poverty or students with disabilities.

This system, which is based on projections of each school’s number and type of students in the upcoming year, is called the weighted student funding formula.

And this year the district changed the formula in order to help balance a projected districtwide budget deficit of up to $50 million.

“Boston Public Schools is entering a difficult budget scenario for Fiscal Year 2017,” Superintendent Tommy Chang said in a statement about the budget. “I have been touched by the tremendous efforts of our school leaders to engage in a thoughtful and caring dialogue about the challenging financial situation before us.”

The new calculations give less weight -- and therefore less money -- to some groups, including high school students, students with autism and students with emotional impairments.

Overall, the district's calculations will cut about $7 million from Boston high schools. But BCLA will be especially hard hit, because in its 15 years it has come to specialize in exactly the types of students that now count for less money.

"One could imagine that it doesn’t really make sense for one school to try and serve all kinds of students with very different needs," Evans said. "Our school has been chosen to focus on students with autism and students with emotional impairments."

A WBUR analysis of state and district data shows that of BCLA’s 527 students, 23 percent have disabilities. And of those students, more than one-third receive school services for autism and emotional impairments.

Next year, the school will receive about $1,300 less for each student with autism, and about $1,000 less for each one with diagnosed emotional difficulties. And despite a waiting list to get into the school, the district projects that BCLA will have 25 fewer students next year.

So, fewer students, with less cash attached to each one. On paper, that costs the school about $300,000 in operational funding.

But what the student funding formula doesn't take into consideration is also quite important: annual increases in teacher salaries.

More Experience, More Money

As teachers stay in the district -- and gain experience -- their salaries increase each year. Teachers who obtain advanced degrees also get higher pay.

And so when the experienced teachers’ salary increases are factored in, BCLA ends up with a shortfall of more than $870,000, according to the school's governing board.

Boston Teachers Union president Richard Stutman says schools may often feel financially penalized for retaining experienced teachers.

"There is by and large, oftentimes, an incentive to hire newer and cheaper teachers, and I think it's counterintuitive, to be frank," Stutman said. "We have schools that purposely look for less expensive teachers, and we have schools that purposely move out more expensive teachers."

BCLA, apparently, is not one of them. And that costs money.

What Comes Next

BCLA staff members know their school needs more money. But they hate the idea of asking for more at the expense of other schools.

So, instead of a bigger slice of the pie, many say they'd like to see a bigger pie.

"I'm hoping that the school district will reconsider the weighted funding formula. I think that's our only hope for this year for all of the schools," said history teacher Nicole Pelletier. "What I’m hoping for even more is that the city council reject the mayor’s budget."

She hopes city councilors will make a stand until more dollars are marked for education. City Councilor Tito Jackson says that's a possibility.

"If the budget does not have the funding that will sustain our Boston Public Schools in the right way," Jackson said, "I would be forced to vote against it this year."

Pelletier has taught at BCLA since 2002. She says the current budget would turn the school into a shell of its former self.

"None of that leadership, advocacy, social justice stuff that this school has been working on developing is going to be there anymore," she said. "So imagine Boston Arts Academy without the arts. The same kind of idea."

She said the decline in district funding will leave teachers with less time and larger classes.

"I think for any school, not just ours, to be put in a situation where you can only do the bare bones -- you’re setting up any school for failure," Pelletier said.

But many students are counting on BCLA to succeed. BCLA high school senior Aliyah Jackson hopes the city or the district finds more funds to save the high school’s leadership academy for future students.

"This is basically our foundation," Jackson said. "If we have a strong foundation in high school, we have a strong future."