Commissioner Recommends State Take Over Southbridge Schools
Mitchell Chester, state commissioner of elementary and secondary education, recommended Friday that Southbridge Public Schools go into state receivership.
If the state board of education approves his recommendation, Southbridge would join Holyoke and Lawrence to become the third Massachusetts district in five years to be taken over by the state.
Citing continued "low academic performance, low graduation rates and unstable leadership," as well as high suspension rates and failure to comply with regulations on teaching English language learners, Chester said in a statement that the district falls short of its duty to provide an effective education.
In his Friday memo to the board, Chester called persistently low performance on standardized tests "by far the most concerning factor" in his decision.
"All of the schools with available data are in the bottom 10 percent of schools statewide," he wrote.
In 2004, the state education board declared Southbridge an underperforming Level 4 district. If the board votes to adopt the commissioner's recommendation, the district will be declared a "chronically underperforming" Level 5 district and a state-appointed receiver will assume control.
A district review prepared by the Massachusetts department of elementary and secondary education in December said leadership is "currently in a state of disarray." Since 2011, seven people have served as superintendent and five as assistant superintendent. A timeline that accompanied Chester's memo details the turnover.
Chester said independent evaluators had "noted some improved practices" at various points. But because of "dysfunctional governance and the district's inability to secure and sustain consistent leadership at any level," the systems the district would need in order to turn around suffered "widespread fragility."
Scott F. Lazo, chairman of the Southbridge school committee, called the December review "a cherry-picked report of various deficiencies." He said it ignores the work a new school committee has been doing since it was elected in July.
"We inherited a disastrous atmosphere and a district under siege," Lazo said Friday. "It seems like the commissioner has not seen the new school committee and the good things that are happening."
The current school committee has named four finalists in its search for a new superintendent. It plans to announce its choice Jan. 26, but state receivership would eliminate the position.
"We've dragged out enough stuff that has hurt kids already," Lazo said. "We don't need to continue that mentality."
Southbridge interim superintendent Timothy Connors said he was not surprised by the commissioner's recommendation.
"I think the district could certainly move forward within the schools with the staff that they have, but I also respect the commissioner's responsibility of doing what he thinks is right," Connors said. "Our responsibility is to work together."
State officials will hold a public meeting to take comments Jan. 25 in Southbridge. The state education board is expected to vote on receivership at its regular Feb. 23 meeting.