What You Need To Know About The Charter Cap
What: Massachusetts currently limits the number of charter schools that can operate in the state. A proposal from the Massachusetts Legislature's Education Committee that would lift the current cap on charter schools has met strong resistance and strong support.
Supporters of traditional public schools argue that lifting the cap -- that is, allowing for more charter schools -- would siphon funding away from traditional schools and districts. Charter school supporters say wait lists are long, demand is high, and that the state should respond by allowing charter schools to expand.
Sen. Sonia Chang-Diaz, a Boston Democrat and co-chair of the Education Committee, has proposed what she calls "a third way:"
A 2010 law requires the state to reimburse school districts 100 percent of per-pupil costs in the first year after a student moves from a conventional public school to a charter school, and 25 percent in each of the following five years.
The state, however, has not fully reimbursed school districts for charter school placements in the last two years and the current state budget falls $28 million short of full funding, lawmakers said.
Under the proposal offered by Chang-Diaz and others, the cap would freeze if reimbursements fell short in future years.
When: Reports from the committee are due today, Tuesday, March 25.
Fast Facts: Charter Schools
There are 81 charter schools in Massachusetts, according to the Department of Elementary and Secondary Education.
Charter schools enroll 34,641 students in Massachusetts, according to state data, accounting for just under 2 percent of the state's K-12 population.
The Legislature last raised the charter school cap in 2010.
Two new charter schools have been approved to open in the fall: Argosy Collegiate Charter School, to enroll 644 students in grades 6-12 in Fall River and Springfield Preparatory Charter School, to enroll 386 students in grades K-8, in Springfield. Atlantis Charter School, in Fall River was approved to expand from K-8 to K-12, increasing enrollment to 583 students.
What it Means
EducationNext: Boston and the Charter School Cap
Imagine you live in a city with a set of open-enrollment public schools, serving predominantly low-income children of color, where students learn at twice the rate of their peers in neighboring schools. And what if those high-performing schools were ready, willing, and able to enroll more students, maybe even double or triple in size? Sounds too good to be true, huh?
Well, that city actually exists, and it’s Boston. But, remarkably, the powers that be are blocking the city’s best schools from growing for the simple reason that they are charter schools.
The current city administration has strongly opposed expansion of Commonwealth charters in Boston. State law specifies the number of Commonwealth charter schools that are allowed statewide and, via spending limits, the number of students who can be enrolled in charter schools in any given district. In 2010, the law was amended to double the number of charter students permitted in the state’s lowest-performing districts, from about 9 percent to 18 percent of public school students. Since then, seven “proven” school operators have been granted charters to expand their operations in Boston.
EdWeek: What a Difference Charter Caps Make....
Obviously, market share isn't everything: Quality of charter school options is even more important, and D.C. has made major strides on this front over the past five years--closing low-performing schools, growing high-performing seats to replace them, and raising the bar for all charters. I've been fortunate to be a part of that. But the contrast between New York and D.C. should also remind us that limits on charter growth can create situations that endanger even high-performing charters--and we shouldn't ignore that these barriers continue to exist in many places where there is high unmet parent demand.
Lowell Sun: To Sen. Chang-Diaz: Don't kill reform bill
New 2014 legislation would give state and local leaders broader authority to revamp underperforming schools. Specifically, the bill would strip the local teachers' union from having to vote to approve reform measures. It would also lift the cap on charter schools in the state's lowest-performing districts. An "Act to Further Narrow the Achievement Gap" is now stuck in the Joint Committee on Education, chaired by Sen. Sonia Chang-Diaz. Despite pleas from 145 Massachusetts business leaders, the Race to the Top Coalition and other education advocates, Chang-Diaz is blocking the initiative from emerging from the committee. It's shameful. This is election-year politicking, in which Chang-Diaz is kowtowing to the teachers' unions and the status quo.
West Roxbury Patch: What’s Wrong with Lifting the Charter Cap?
The simple truth is that charter schools are part of a strategy used by the corporate sector to discredit public schools with the goal of privatizing education. By hiring mainly recent college graduates who will not stay in the profession long enough to attain professional status, a charter school saves on benefits, pay raises commensurate with experience, and paying into a pension system. By closing buildings and giving them to charter schools, the city not only sheds those costs, but will save on maintenance, as well.
Massachusetts Charter Public School Association: Carrying on the Mantle of Reform
The battle over charter schools is largely a political ploy that undermines substantive policy work. Charters have been proven good models where students thrive and succeed. So have most traditional public schools in Massachusetts. Our goal should be to encourage schools that work while reforming schools that don’t—which is exactly what An Act to Further Narrow the Achievement Gap does
“There can be no doubt that parents across Boston and the state support more charter schools in their communities,” saidMarc Kenen, Executive Director of the Massachusetts Charter Public School Association. “We are hopeful the Committee will hear their calls, and approve a bill that lifts the cap on charter schools without compromising their future.”
Boston Globe: Education reform has worked for Mass.; it’s time for the next round
Advocates on both sides can argue these points all night. But the goal isn’t to fuel a war between traditional public schools and charters; it’s to develop the most effective education policies and then apply them broadly. The fact that charter schools are making a significant effort to enroll students with special needs, and to test-market innovative techniques to get them up to the level of other kids, is of enormous benefit to Massachusetts as a whole — not just the students who happen to win the charter-school lottery.
Charter schools aren’t a replacement for traditional public schools. Currently, only 1 in 8 Boston public-school students is in a charter. Raising the cap would only change that ratio slightly. And school districts are given sufficient time to adjust to any loss of students. When kids leave for charters, the system gets a full reimbursement for one year, and a 25 percent reimbursement for five more years. When the Legislature funds the reimbursement formula at or near the target, as it generally has, there’s more than enough money to cushion any blow.
Boston Municipal Research Bureau: Education Bill Important for Level 3 School Reforms
This bill also eliminates the cap on the number of Horace Mann in-district charter schools in the lowest 10% of the Commonwealth’s school districts. This provision of the bill would apply to Boston and 14 other school districts. Boston now has six Horace Mann charter schools which provide charter flexibility and are funded through the School Department budget so they do not cause state Chapter 70 funds to leave the system. The bill also provides that Horace Mann charter schools established in one of the lowest 10% performing districts could be renewed without approval of the local collective bargaining unit.
Boston Globe: Proposal to end charter deadlock on Beacon Hill raises doubts
“What little we know of the current compromise would allow lawmakers to stop the expansion of charters to plan a responsible course of multiyear growth by simply voting to underfund the reimbursement by a single dollar,” said Paul S. Grogan, president and chief executive officer of the Boston Foundation, on behalf of the coalition.
Boston Globe: Hundreds of parents band together to oppose charter school expansion
Hundreds of parents with children in the Boston school system have launched a spirited campaign to halt efforts on Beacon Hill to open more charter schools in the city and elsewhere.
The parents say that cities and the state cannot afford to fund additional schools, pointing out for instance that the Boston school system is facing budget cuts.
Members of the group have been meeting with key lawmakers, testifying at legislative hearings, and circulating an online petition advocating against a bill that would lift a state-imposed cap on charter school enrollment. As of Sunday, thepetition had received more than 2,200 signatures.
Gloucester Daily Times: Impact on traditional schools fuels charter debate
“I have been on record in both words and action that I am committed to getting a bill out of committee that continues to close the gap between populations served by charters and districts, mitigates the financial stresses that even the best charters present for school districts, and allows targeted expansion of good charters,” Sen. Sonia Chang-Diaz said in a statement released after the Education Committee voted last week to request an extension to give it more time to work on a charter school reform bill.
“To that end, I’ve offered multiple proposals for balanced compromises. These proposals have been met with consistent ‘no’s’ from the charter advocate community, with no counter proposals that bring us toward a compromise,” she said. “While I am disappointed that we must resort to a one-week extension today, I remain committed to forging a resolution.
“My door is wide open to anyone who has ideas about how we can move forward on a middle path that treats all kids with compassion and fairness,” said Chang-Diaz, a Jamaica Plain Democrat who co-chairs the committee.
For more background, check out this FAQ from the Department of Elementary and Secondary Education: