New Charter School Bill: A Higher Cap, Challenge Schools And Opt-Out Lotteries
A last-minute compromise bill would allow more students to attend charter schools in the state's lowest performing districts and create a new class of "challenge schools" that would have more autonomy while staying within the district system.
"The subject matter of this bill, I think was too important, to die by using procedural rules and not allowing the bill to advance so there could be a full debate in the Legislature," Education Committee Co-chair Rep. Alice Peisch told Statehouse News Service Wednesday.
Here's how the charter cap works now: In most districts, only 9 percent of school spending can go to charter schools. For the lowest performing districts (the bottom 10th percentile of MCAS scores) this cap is higher, 15 percent this year and rising to 18 percent in 2017.
This bill doesn't deal with reimbursement for districts, an issue which sank a previous compromise proposal. The state is supposed to reimburse districts for lost revenue when students transfer to charters, but current state budget is $28 million short of full reimbursement.
Statehouse News Service has more on how the bill came together.
Here's what the bill would mean:
Raising the cap, for some
Spending on charters could rise to 23 percent of school spending by 2022, but only in the bottom 10th percentile districts, which already allow more charters than the rest of the state.
For the 2012-13 school year, the higher cap applied to these 29 districts:
- Adams-Cheshire
- Athol-Royalston
- Boston
- Brockton
- Chelsea
- Everett
- Fall River
- Fitchburg
- Gardner
- Haverhill
- Hawlemont
- Holyoke
- Lawrence
- Lowell
- Lynn
- Methuen
- New Bedford
- North Adams
- Orange
- Provincetown
- Randolph
- Salem
- Somerville
- Southbridge
- Springfield
- Ware
- Webster
- Winchendon
- Worcester
The proposed compromise wouldn't change the statewide limit of 120 charters. There are currently 81 operating charter schools in the state.
"Challenge Schools"
Challenge schools are those at the bottom of Level 3, not quite underperforming but close enough to warrant attention. Here's how Statehouse News Service summarized it:
According to a bill summary, Peisch's bill (H 3984) authorizes the education commissioner to designate a subset of Level 3 schools as "challenge schools," which include schools that score in the lowest performing 20 percent statewide that are most likely to be designated as underperforming (Level 4). "Challenge schools" would be required to develop two-year turnaround plans, similar to the turnaround plans required for underperforming (Level 4) and chronically underperforming (Level 5) schools.
These would still be district schools, not charters.
An opt-out lottery
Charters opening under the rules in this bill would have to accept students using an "opt-out lottery." Here's how Rep. Peisch's office summarized the policy:
Under the "opt-out" lottery process, all students who would be eligible to attend the charter school under the district's assignment policy if it were a district school shall be deemed eligible for enrollment in the charter school without any required application process for the school, and shall be automatically included in the lottery. Parents of students selected for admission through the opt-out lottery process may choose not to accept the admission offer.
The full text of the bill is embedded below: