Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

Five Takeaways From Mitchell Chester On Learning In The 21st century

In a wide-ranging conversation about the future of education nationally and locally, Massachusetts Education Commissioner Mitchell Chester on Thursday spoke at Harvard's Graduate School of Education about evaluating teachers, the role of charter schools, and building education leadership, among other topics.

Chester was one of several panelists at the Ed School's "Ask With" forum titled Educational Challenges of the 21st Century. Other panelists included:

  • Deb Delisle, Assistant Secretary for Elementary and Secondary Education, U.S. Department of Education
  • Fernando Reimers, Ed.M.’84, Ed.D.’88, Ford Foundation Professor of International Education, and director, International Education Policy Program, HGSE
  • Amar Bhidé, Thomas Schmidheiny Professor, The Fletcher School, Tufts University
  • Michael Casserly, Executive Director, Council of the Great City Schools
  • Nancy Hoffman, Vice President and Senior Advisor, Jobs for the Future; Adjunct Lecturer on Education, HGSE

Read Learning Lab's five takeaways from Chester's remarks below (minor edits have been made for clarity):

Teacher evaluations are necessary, but complex.

There is incredible evidence that there is great variation among teachers in terms of their ability to secure student learning.

There are teachers who routinely, year after year, get tremendous learning gains from their kids. There are teachers who routinely, year after year, get pretty poor gains from their students. Only recently have we started to measure that.

We can be pretty confident about people at the tails, the highest performers and the lowest performers. We don't do a great job [measuring effectiveness] in the middle.

I would never advocate reducing teaching performance or teaching impact to a single number. I do think evidence of student learning is an important indicator of the effectiveness of the teacher and I don't want to ignore it.

For too long in too many places we didn't do a good job of distinguishing, particularly at the tails, and we now know in ways that we didn't know, couldn't quantify as well ten or fifteen years ago that there is this variation.

Low performing teachers, ineffective teachers, are damaging kids. The trajectory of kids academic progress, if they have those low teachers versus more effective teachers, is hugely different. We cannot shy away from taking that on and looking at that."

(at 1:02:00 and 1:27:15 in the video)

Identifying and incubating leadership for schools and districts is "a major issue."

Where that leadership pipeline is going to come from, particularly folks who are ready to take on assignments that are not easy assignments, where you're inheriting an institution, a school, that has, over time, atrophied, and there's a culture of accepting and not taking that on.

Leadership preparation is huge. This is a place where the federal government needs to be investing in incentivizing. I'd do it on a competitive basis, incentivizing programs to cultivate, develop leadership, particularly leadership for tough assignments, for schools that are struggling.

I think a component of that has to be sufficient running room. I don't think you can hire somebody in August for that assignment a month later. I think what some of the strongest charter schools and turnaround operators are doing is they're identifying that leadership a year in advance, giving that leadership a chance to be on the ground for a year, asses the assets and liabilities in the institution, garner a staff."

(at 38:30 and 1:45:33 in the video)

The lessons of charter schools have not been well learned.

Massachusetts set a very high bar for what it takes to get a charter school and maintain a charter. Most of the charter schools, particularly in Massachusetts urban districts are very high performing.

Where we've failed is one of the theories on charters schools was that they would be laboratories of innovation that would inform the rest of the system. And we just had this an impermeable wall between the charter school community and the traditional school community. There's a lot to be learned in both directions."

(at 1:04:53 in the video)

Education data is useful, but not always well utilized.

"Most states at this point have fairly rich data deposits, warehouses, and are developing pretty substantial databases, typically longitudinal in nature so that we can, in Massachusetts, and I don't think we're unique, we know the trajectory of students' experiences in schooling and as they move up through the grades we can calculate the degree to which students are progressing well and not progressing well."

Chester said a lot of the schools he visits have a "data wall."

Every few weeks they are assessing kids. When I ask questions about how they use it, often times I'm less than confident in how it's being used.

(at 1:00:00 in the video)

Students struggle because of what happens to them outside of school.

In schools we do a pretty good job overall in working with kids when we have them. And that much of the [achievement] gap that we see among students is attributable to factors outside of school.

I'll be the last one to let the schools off the hook for getting the job done, for the time that they do have the students, but we do have to think about how to expand opportunities for students beyond the traditional school day, whether it's summer, whether it's after-school or otherwise.

(at 39:10 in the video)