Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

Report: Boston Schools Need More Autonomy

How much autonomy should Boston schools have? More is better, says a report presented at The Boston Foundation today. The full report is embedded below.

Paul Grogan, president of The Boston Foundation, spoke to WBUR's Bob Oakes on Morning Edition today. (Learning Lab is funded in part by a grant from The Boston Foundation.)

The first charter schools in Massachusetts opened 20 years ago. Within Boston Public Schools, the district allows a third of its schools some degree of autonomy.

Autonomy can mean that a school is responsible for making decisions related to its curriculum, staffing, partnerships and more.

"It's very, very clear these schools are doing much better overall," Grogan said. "They are very popular with the public. They're being over-chosen in the school lottery." Principals, too, are fans, he said.

But the teachers union is wary. Richard Stutman, president of the Boston Teachers Union, told the Globe:

"On the one hand, many parents are demanding choice, and autonomous schools, as distinct from traditional schools, gives the illusion of choice. On the other hand, granting autonomy to more and more schools, like charters, will eventually lead to a dissolution of the public school system as we know it."

Grogan, responding to Stutman, said the criticism is overblown: "It's public education. It's free and universal and held to standards."

He added, "The unions have to look at the future."

BPS interim superintendent John McDonough asked Education Resource Strategies and the Center for Collaborative Education to conduct the study, which deeply examined BPS and made comparisons to other school districts including Lawrence, Mass., New York City and Baltimore.

"We've been on a pathway that has sought different ways to get flexibility for school leaders for a long time," McDonough said. "This work has allowed us to determine under which conditions [school autonomy is successful]."

BPS operates a variety of types of autonomous schools including Horace Mann charters, innovation schools and pilot schools. Next year, about 32 percent of BPS students are expected to be enrolled in an autonomous school.

BPS is still searching for a new superintendent. Grogan said the district office as a whole needs to find a new mission. It can't be an "overseer" anymore.

"It needs to be converted to a service corporation that is providing services to schools that are operating much more independently than it was before," Grogan said on Morning Edition.

The report's seven recommendations are that BPS:

  • Operate as a "system of schools."
  • Extend maximum flexibility to all district schools.
  • Decentralize non-core central services
  • Incubate and oversee development of new school models at the Cabinet level
  • Support school leaders and their teams in making strategic resource decisions.
  • Implement a clear and equitable accountability system for all schools.
  • Prioritize Superintendent candidates with the capacity to unite people around this vision.

Read the full report below: