5 Questions with Nick Donohue, President of the Nellie Mae Education Foundation

In the past 12 months, the Nellie Mae Education Foundation has spent more than $12 million on education programming, policy and research. Nearly $2.5 million of that funding has gone to Massachusetts, to schools like the Boston Day & Evening Academy and Revere High School, as well as foundations like The Boston Foundation, Bellwether Education Partners and Massachusetts Business Alliance for Education.
This week, Nellie Mae Foundation President and CEO Nick Donohue sat down with Learning Lab to talk about the Foundation's investments.
Donohue's focus is "student-centered learning," which Donohue says can improve student drop-out rates and better prepare students for post-secondary education.
"It's the idea that if you want a lot of people to learn, you need to get more personalized and meet kids where they are really--where their interests are, with what's relevant to them-- and customizing learning," Donohue said.
Donohue answers our questions about this approach, and more, below.
You describe student-centered learning as a “playlist.” Can you explain?
A playlist describes the personalized set of approaches that are most appropriate for a particular learner. It describes the variety of engagement strategies that are most effective for the student.
Sometimes a real world internship might be indicated. Sometimes it’s self-directed work. Sometimes it’s traditional classroom instruction. Like a playlist the variety of experiences can be drawn from a limited universe of options because delivering the experiences needs to meet some feasibility test.
However, being open to student and teacher directed attention to options off the traditional grid of a particular district “song bank” is important.
Some schools and districts rely heavily on foundation support. Other eschew it completely. What is the right role for foundations in education right now? Is it classroom-based? Policy-based? Research-based?
It should be a combination of all three efforts and possibly a fourth, if a foundation has the capacity to do so. The mission of the Nellie Mae Education Foundation is to stimulate transformative change of public education systems across New England.
One way that we approach this is by supporting several initiatives to create and sustain changes in practice at the district level, creating new models for systems change, trying new approaches in urban districts, and building a culture that is open and collaborative to the type of change that our mission mandates.
Another approach is through policy, we support policy work, reports, and groups that promote and advocate for the policies that create the conditions under which student-centered learning can be adopted and thrive.
We also have a research initiative that examines student-centered learning practices in education and disseminates the findings to practitioners to use and implement.
A fourth initiative involves communication and fostering public awareness, understanding, support and cultivating demand for student-centered learning practices. This last piece of work is locally oriented but also includes aspirations to build broader alliances as well.
How do you measure success in your grants?
When measuring our success, we look at the increase in evidence that SCL approaches are working and the increase in knowledge and understanding of the SCL landscape, practices, and outcomes.
We look at the schools that we fund and whether they were able to increase capacity to implement specific SCL approaches. We look at the types of changes in public policy that are needed to support equitable SCL and the increase in SCL supportive public policy changes in targeted New England states and districts. And finally, we look at the increase in understanding of SCL approaches to education by target audiences; the increase in support for equitable SCL demonstrated by target stakeholders; and the increase in demand for equitable SCL approaches.
Recently we have adopted a more focused Big Goal around which we hope to build alliances and growing momentum based on increasing the number of New England students that are college or career ready by a certain date. Currently, we estimate that 50% of New England area high school students are adequately prepared for success in college or the workforce. While all students should be prepared to graduate and succeed, Nellie Mae Education Foundation and its partners have set a goal of growing that number to 80% by the year 2030.
Where do you see interesting movement or conversations that are off-the-radar right now?
There is some very interesting movement taking place in northern New England right now, in Maine in particular and largely due to the state’s adoption of LD1422, an act to prepare Maine’s people for the future economy by requiring all public school districts to implement a proficiency-based diploma system by 2018.
Most of the news coverage of this has been local or regional and somewhat off the national radar. It’s an interesting movement, nevertheless, because New Hampshire did the same thing, too, requiring all school districts to implement personalization and a competency-based diploma by 2015. I think these are the first fruits of a long-awaited movement to change the US education system.
And here in Massachusetts, Revere High School was a designated Level 3 school that adopted blended learning two years ago and now it’s a Level 1 school. It also won the National Urban Education Award just weeks ago. This is a school that has a high transiency rate, where 80 percent of the students are low-income and are predominantly students of color. In other parts of the country, students of color and low-income students are setting trends as a result of SCL, thus proving that this approach to teaching and learning works.
Further afield, there is growing dissatisfaction with the narrow, test based frame around which education has been working. The most interesting conversation edge is the variety of places where people are remembering that education is historically a public good to be cherished, not just a private good to be purchased.
We need individuals to succeed for our communities to flourish, and there is growing understanding to making sure a wide variety of people of all backgrounds, income levels, races and ethnicities need to progress if our society is going to progress. We are a nation of individuals but we are also a society joined by our commitment to progress, justice and democracy.
What has changed in the past ten years in New England education? And what’s on the horizon for the next ten?
Over the last ten years, we have seen more innovative practices take root in education, but as they take hold the public is still treating education as a means to individual achievement when the truth of the matter is that every student should have access to the knowledge, skills and social experiences needed to succeed. The vision for the future is for the conversation to shift to being about education as a means of lifting all boats towards a healthier democracy and a more informed citizenry.
Over the past ten years we have made big gains in identifying the differences in outcomes between groups of learners. We now know low-income kids, kids of color and other groups do not fare as well because of one size fits all approaches to learning and deep inequities between communities in terms of resources for education.
More recently, education technology is taking hold. While this takes the form of an electronic textbook in too many places, this phenomenon will allow a deep renovation of education toward a more student-centered framework because it will allow deeper customization and better tracking of data to identify what should come next for each learner.
The four biggest future edges of education and education reform are going to be 1) big data; 2) a realization that life conditions matter; 3) a re-embracing of educators as the local heroes and civic leaders and; 4) a broad public dialogue about the purposes of education in a democracy.
Big data will allow just in time disaggregation of information about students and their experiences that will allow deep personalization.
A growing understanding that deep social and economic inequities are an essential complement to renovating and redefining student engagement will result in a change in how we think about accountability. How well is a community organizing to make sure everyone is prepared?
Educators will be seen as essential leaders of education and valued workers in our society.
The fourth trend will trump the others – public engagement and leadership around education and education reform. As federal oversight and direction wanes, local and state communities will be pressed to reflect on the purposes of education in our society. Community leaders and the general public will engage in fierce dialogue and debate about how education must and will change. This will result in a new age of innovation and R&D in education that will finally catch up with our world leadership in these ways in so many other fields.