Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

Report: Black And Latino Students On A Separate, Lesser Educational Track In Boston

A new report released Thursday says black and Latino males are slipping through the cracks. (Stephen Savoia/AP)
A new report released Thursday says black and Latino males are slipping through the cracks. (Stephen Savoia/AP)

White and Asian male students in Boston's schools are 1.2 times more likely to graduate than their black male peers and 1.4 times more likely than Latino males in the district, according to a city-commissioned report released Thursday.

In what some are calling an educational crisis, the report outlines that black and Latino males are lagging substantially behind peers on MCAS scores, high school graduation and attendance rates, while outperforming peers in suspension and dropout rates.

A Two-Track System

The report, which examined data between 2009 and 2012, suggests a troubling reality: Boston may have two school systems -- one that provides white and Asian males with the best learning opportunities and a separate, removed one for black and Latino students with diminished educational opportunities.

The report's release comes at a time when Boston's educational community is marking the 40th anniversary of Boston's court-ordered school desegregation. The report highlights concerns that inequities in education still exist today.

Disparities in educational access and resources, the report says, "translates into lower lifelong prospects, including restricted college and career opportunities."

For example, large imbalances are present in access and enrollment in Advanced Work Class programs, an accelerated academic curriculum for students in grades 4-6. Although black and Latino males made up 79.2 percent of male enrollment in those grades in 2012, they accounted for less than half of male enrollment in AWC.

These disparities continue and are amplified by the time students reach high school, where black and Latino students are 3.2 and 2.3 times more likely, respectively, to be suspended than a white male.

In Boston's prestigious exam schools, 8.6 percent of black males and 8 percent of Latinos were enrolled in 2012. Compare this with their peers: 45 percent of white and 47.8 percent of Asian males were enrolled in exam schools in 2012.

"There is no rational justification for a two-track system," the report says, "especially one that begins in fourth grade."

Black And Latino Special Needs Students Face More Hardships Than Peers

Research indicates that students with disabilities who are instructed in general education settings tend to have better outcomes than students with special needs who are removed and educated in more restrictive settings.

However, black and Latino male students with special needs are disproportionately enrolled in substantially separate classrooms. In 2012, black male students were enrolled in separate settings at twice the rate and Latino male students at 1.6 times the rate of white male students.

In contrast, white male elementary grade level students with special were more likely to be placed in general education settings at a rate that was 1.5 times greater than that for Latino male students, and 1.7 times greater than that for black male students.

Report Recommendations

The report was prepared by the Center for Collaborative Education, a Boston-based nonprofit, and the Annenberg Institute for School Reform at Brown University. The report offers several recommendations, some of which are likely to cause controversy.

The Boston Globe reports:

For instance, it recommends converting every classroom in grades 4 to 6 into advanced-work programs. The program, a gateway into the exam schools, enrolls few black and Latino males. But the recommendation would probably stir debate about whether all students are ready for that rigor or whether advanced work would be watered down.

Other recommendations endorse efforts already underway, such as expanding early childhood education and the diversity of the teaching force, and stepping up efforts to train teachers on any unintentional biases against others of different races. That latter area could address why black and Latino males are disciplined or suspended at higher rates.

The report, which was released during an event at City Year Boston, is believed to be the most comprehensive analysis of the performance of black and Latino males in Boston schools.