Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

Why Mass. Educators Are Calling For A Halt To High-Stakes Testing

Educators across the state are calling for a three-year moratorium on high-stakes testing. (Steve Ruark/AP)
Educators across the state are calling for a three-year moratorium on high-stakes testing. (Steve Ruark/AP)

BOSTON -- The debate is raging in Massachusetts education: Which standardized test will be best for Massachusetts' school children? Massachusetts Comprehensive Assessment System (MCAS) or Partnership for Assessment for College and Careers (PARCC)?

While state education officials are expected to answer that question this fall, for a growing group of Massachusetts educators the answer is simple: neither.

"The problem with high-stakes testing is that it narrows the curriculum," says Barbara Madeloni, president of the Massachusetts Teachers Association (MTA), the state's largest teachers union. "There's whole swathes of what's important about public education and about a child's experience in school that are not acknowledged in testing."

What Is High-Stakes Testing?

High-stakes testing is any testing that carries the potential for significant consequences based on the score. For students, they're tests they must pass in order to graduate. For teachers, they're tests with scores that could affect their evaluations. And for districts, they're test scores that determine whether the district could go into receivership.

And they're all qualities that make up the MCAS and PARCC tests.

"The idea that we can know something about the quality of teaching based on the test scores students produce on a standardized test is outrageous," Madeloni says. "It doesn’t at all address the complexity of teaching or the real work that teachers do every day."

The tests might not accurately address the learning that students do, either.

A recent Washington University research paper shows that high-stakes standardized tests may be a better indicator of socioeconomic status than anything else, thus exacerbating existing achievement gaps along class lines. It found that children from wealthier communities outscored poorer children by as much as 60 percent on standardized tests.

"The plethora of state-high-stakes-tests has created a new dilemma: achieving social justice in the public schools," said Donald C. Orlich, the paper's author. "The poor, disfranchised, minority and disabled children have fallen into education's 'achievement gap.'"

Other concerns have been raised by the amount of time testing can take away from learning time.

A report by the American Federation of Teachers shows that the time that students take tests can range from 20 to 50 hours per year. In addition, students can spend 60 to more than 110 hours per year in test prep in high-stakes testing grades.

A Look To The Legislature

Now, Madeloni and MTA teachers, disgruntled with the amount of high-stakes testing, have turned to the Massachusetts State House to air their concerns about high-stakes testing.

They're part of a group of education organizations behind a bill calling for a halt to high-stakes testing. The proposed bill, sponsored by Rep. Marjorie Decker (D-Cambridge), calls for a three-year moratorium on the implementation of PARCC and to remove the "high stakes" nature of the existing MCAS tests.

Other supporting groups include the American Federation of Teachers, the Boston Teachers Union, Citizens for Public Schools and the Greater Boston Labor Council.

During that time, the bill would establish a task force of students, parents, educators, policy makers, legislators and other community members to examine the effect of high-stakes testing in schools.

Support, Worries From Across The State

And the MTA and the groups behind the proposed bill are not alone in their call.

On Monday, Cambridge councilors went on record to support the MTA's proposed bill. The Amherst-Pelham Regional school committee voted unanimously on Tuesday to favor a moratorium on high-stakes testing.

Last week, the Worcester School Committee formally backed the call to put a freeze on high-stakes testing. Tracy Novick, a Worcester School Committee member who endorsed the move, has seen testing change the way schools operate in a way she calls a "distraction."

"We’ve seen it dominate a lot of what we’re doing, really kind of taking out a lot of the oxygen in the room, that, in many ways, we’d like to devote to other things," says Novick.

Novick argues that the emphasis on standardized testing in schools goes against the very laws which created it.

Massachusetts education reform laws passed in 1993 call for "a variety of assessment instruments" to measure "student performance, and to improve the effectiveness of curriculum and instruction."

"It's amazing to me how we have avoided what the law actually says," Novick says. "There's basically no way that is has any resemblance to MCAS or PARCC."

But not all agree with the proposed freeze.

Cambridge Councilor and state Rep. Timothy Toomey who voted against Cambridge's policy told the Cambridge Chronicle that he was worried that students could be negatively impacted by the move.

"Once these things go away there's not going to be any accountability," he said. "No other standard is going to come in."

A hearing on Bill H.340, An Act relative to a moratorium on high stakes testing and PARCC, is scheduled before the Joint Committee on Education on June 11 at 10:00 a.m.