Senate's Revised Education Bill Passes, Without Warren's Vote

Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) was one of just three Democrats to vote against the Every Child Achieves Act, the Senate's revision of the education law known as No Child Left Behind, which passed Thursday by a vote of 81-17.
While she called the measure "a significant improvement in federal education policy," Warren said in a statement that it "eliminates basic, fundamental safeguards to ensure that federal dollars are actually used to improve both schools and educational outcomes for those students who are often ignored."
Warren supported the bill in committee because, she said, she was promised that "it would improve." But "in the past two weeks, Republicans have blocked every attempt to establish even minimum safeguards to ensure that money would be used effectively," she said. "I cannot support this legislation until this critical issue is meaningfully addressed."
The bill now goes to conference with the House of Representatives, which passed its own revision of NCLB last week. Critics in the Senate have called that version, which reduces federal oversight more than their act would, too partisan, and other substantial differences remain.
In addition, the White House has suggested that President Obama would veto the House version. The administration's statement on the Senate bill, before its passage, was less severe but called for both increasing accountability and reducing the time spent on standardized tests.
Warren and the other two Democrats who voted against the Senate bill, New Jersey's Cory Booker and Chris Murphy of Connecticut, had proposed an amendment that, they said, would have increased accountability for underperforming schools. That amendment failed along partisan lines, and other Democrats who had sponsored it -- Chris Coons (Delaware), Dick Durbin (Illinois), Dianne Feinstein (California) and Barbara Mikulski (Maryland) all voted in favor of the final bill, even without the amendment.
The issue of accountability -- and of how to measure a school's success or failure, which is key to holding it accountable -- has been one of the most contentious issues since the passage of No Child Left Behind in 2001. Some critics say NCLB relies too heavily on standardized test results, a concern Warren noted in her statement, while others attack what they see as excessive federal interference in states' education policies.
The Senate bill -- and, most likely, any compromise that may come out of conference -- will likely not fully satisfy critics on either side.
“This gives us about 80 percent of what we want,” said Sen. Lamar Alexander (R-Tenn.) shortly before the final vote on the bipartisan bill, which he sponsored with Sen. Patty Murray (D-Wash.). “If you vote ‘no’ we fix nothing.”
After the vote, however, he did note the one point on which nearly everyone -- both in Congress and outside of it -- seems to agree.
"Everyone wants to fix No Child Left Behind," Alexander said. "That's the consensus we began with."