Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

Boston Proposes Combining Charter, District Enrollment Applications

In this January 2014 photo, families submit their applications for BPS fall enrollment in kindergarten, sixth and twelfth grades at the Dorchester Welcome Center. (Jesse Costa/WBUR/File)
In this January 2014 photo, families submit their applications for BPS fall enrollment in kindergarten, sixth and twelfth grades at the Dorchester Welcome Center. (Jesse Costa/WBUR/File)

BOSTON -- Boston students would be able to apply simultaneously to charter and district schools under a proposal that Mayor Marty Walsh plans to release Thursday.  It comes just as Boston students file a lawsuit to lift the charter cap in the state.

Currently, families enter one lottery for district seats and another for each charter school they wish to apply to. Under the proposed system, families would enter the same home-based Boston Public Schools lottery for both public and charter schools.

"[The plan would] provide one application, one portal and one deadline for parents who want to make choices and who need to make choices about schools," Rahn Dorsey, chief of education for the City of Boston, told WBUR. The proposal is being handled by Dorsey and Rachel Weinstein, chief collaboration officer for the Boston Compact.

The proposed plan could also effectively change charter schools that opt into the enrollment process from citywide schools to neighborhood schools. Currently charter schools may accept students from throughout the city. Under the proposed process, Weinstein said, students would be given a choice of charter schools based on where they live, just as they are for district schools.

But the district school home-based assignment process itself has come under fire in the past. Because of Boston's racial geography, critics argue, it can create segregated schools.

"We're not suggesting anything new; we're just saying, 'Let's bring the charters into the home-based assignment,' and I know that resurfaces the question, 'Are we re-segregating?'" said Weinstein. "I think we need to take a really careful look at that and see how the implementation is going and see what, if any, adjustments are needed."

Weinstein said it's unprecedented to have school officials from district and charter schools coming together to consider the process.

"We have been working together really well for four years and building a common understanding of the city and its needs," said Weinstein. "This is a bold next step."

This comes in the midst of a long-running battle over public charter schools, which are controversial because they divert thousands of dollars in state aid from public schools for each student they enroll, operate apart from local districts, do not need to be unionized and have a legacy of harsher discipline practices. Supporters say the schools provide valuable options for parents beyond district schools.

To help Boston parents through the enrollment process, city officials say, the proposed process will lay out comparable data on performance and school characteristics for district and charter schools.

Heshan Berents-Weeramuni, Boston Public Schools parent and co-chair of the Boston Citywide Parents Council, expressed concern that the new enrollment process -- and a possible increase in charter school applicants -- could allow charter schools to "cherry-pick" which students they accept through a lottery, especially when it comes to English-language learners and students with disabilities.

"I am skeptical that charter school districts that are built on that model would, necessarily, have their standardized test scores plummet because these kids may be harder for them to educate and keep," said Berents-Weeramuni.

Before going into effect, the proposed plan would require approval by the Boston school committee and  the state Legislature. The city will hold six meetings, beginning Oct. 8, for public comment.

WBUR’s Qainat Khan contributed to this report.