Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

Group Sues To Lift Massachusetts Charter Cap

In this image made from video, chairs sit empty in a classroom of Hunt Elementary School in Fort Valley, Ga., on Monday, May 17, 2010. (Peter Prengaman/AP)
In this image made from video, chairs sit empty in a classroom of Hunt Elementary School in Fort Valley, Ga., on Monday, May 17, 2010. (Peter Prengaman/AP)

BOSTON -- Arguing that the charter school cap unconstitutionally denies children access to an adequate education, three lawyers from top Boston firms filed a class-action lawsuit Tuesday to lift the cap.

Paul Ware Jr., Michael Keating and William Lee filed suit in Suffolk Superior Court on behalf of five Boston students who were denied spots at charter schools. Charter school seats are assigned by lottery and are limited by state law.

"The charter school cap stands in the way, arbitrarily, of some children obtaining that constitutionally mandated minimally adequate education," said Lee, a partner at WilmerHale. That standard comes from the Massachusetts Constitution.

Charter school supporters say the schools, which do not have to be unionized and may set their own curricula, are some of the few alternatives for low-income children and families who are unhappy with the public education system. Critics say the schools take away money and resources from public schools.

"The record is that public school districts have lost millions of dollars to charter schools after state reimbursements," said Lisa Guisbond, executive director of Citizens for Public Schools. "If we lift the cap, those losses will just get much bigger, meaning district school students lose access to important educational opportunities, as we’ve seen already happen. Things like art, music, phys ed, access to social workers."

Under current law, the state may direct up to 9 percent of the money the district spends on students to fund seats at local charter schools. In low-performing school districts like Boston, the state can direct up to 18 percent of that spending to fund charter schools before it is capped.

The state has a fund to reimburse school districts for some of the money sent to charter schools, but the reimbursements do not fully offset the amount of money districts must give to charters.

Statewide, local school districts paid about $367 million last year in tuition to the state's 80 charter schools, after state reimbursements.

Barbara Madeloni, president of the Massachusetts Teachers Association, which strongly opposes charter schools, says that charter schools create a parallel system of schools.

"One of the things that we know about whenever we create two-tiered systems is that it’s primarily going to hurt black and brown children, primarily going to hurt poor children," said Madeloni.

The class action lawsuit lists as defendants Gov. Charlie Baker's secretary of education, James Peyser, the chair of the board of elementary and secondary education, Paul Sagan, the commissioner of elementary and secondary education, Mitchell Chester, and other top education officials.

In a statement, Lizzy Guyton, Baker's press secretary, said the administration "does not comment on pending litigation."

“The Governor has consistently supported raising the charter school cap and continues to strongly believe that all students should have access to high quality schools, especially in underperforming districts," Guyton said in the statement.