MCAS Scores Rise As State Also Releases First PARCC Results

BOSTON -- At most grade levels, a higher percentage of students scored proficient or higher on the 2015 MCAS tests than in 2014, according to figures released Monday. In addition, the same proportion of sophomores -- 88 percent -- passed this year's test on their first try as did in 2014.
The results for this year's MCAS, the Massachusetts Comprehensive Assessment System standardized tests, were released along with the first Massachusetts results for PARCC, the Partnership for Assessment for Readiness for College and Careers (PARCC) test, which were lower overall than the MCAS results.
State officials cautioned, however, against comparing the two tests directly because the PARCC data is preliminary. It includes only those students who took the test on computers; results for the handful of districts that used pencil and paper are due out by November.
The MCAS results also indicate that, while white students continue to score higher than their peers, the achievement gap is narrowing, officials said.
"I am pleased to see the MCAS scores reflect continued progress in narrowing some of the achievement gaps that persist between groups of students," education commissioner Mitchell Chester said in a statement.
Students overall struggled most with the MCAS assessment of seventh-grade math. Only half scored proficient or higher, and almost one in four -- 23 percent -- received a failing grade.
The preliminary PARCC results showed that, in most grades, students who took PARCC math and English tests on computers were less likely to receive top scores than their counterparts who took pen-and-paper MCAS exams.
In six of the 12 computer PARCC exams given to students in grades 3 through 8, a majority of students received marks indicating they did not "meet expectations."
"This early report on PARCC results is preliminary and incomplete and therefore cannot yet be directly compared to this year’s MCAS results," education secretary Jim Peyser said in a statement.
State officials are scheduled to decide in November whether to keep using MCAS or switch to PARCC. In preparation for that vote, Massachusetts is conducting a two-year test of PARCC, which began with the 2015 test.
The possible switch has stirred controversy. PARCC supporters say the Common Core-aligned test has higher standards, can better track student progress and embraces technology. Critics say there has been little proof of the higher standards and argue that, because students in poorer districts may not have the same access to computers, a technological divide could contribute to an achievement gap.
Linda Noonan, executive director of Massachusetts Business Alliance for Education, which strongly supports PARCC, said she hopes that switching would help expand access to educational technology.
"If the test is what leverages our state to get to where it needs to be in providing technological resources to students and teachers, then so be it," said Noonan. "That's the lever."
Tracy Novick, member of the Worcester School Committee, a district where some students took PARCC, says that the state's district funding formula doesn't cover technology updates.
"The expectation that districts were magically coming up with this money anyway, and it was just supposed to be something that happened, is something that the state really fell down on," said Novick.
The state will release district-by-district and individual school MCAS and PARCC results Thursday.