Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

Detailed MCAS Results: Mostly Up, But Some Concerns

Mitchell Chester, Massachusetts commissioner of elementary and secondary education, says he is “very pleased” overall with the 2015 MCAS results, despite some concerns. (Peter Balonon-Rosen/WBUR)
Mitchell Chester, Massachusetts commissioner of elementary and secondary education, says he is “very pleased” overall with the 2015 MCAS results, despite some concerns. (Peter Balonon-Rosen/WBUR)

Updated at 12:06 p.m. 9/24/2015

Mitchell Chester, Massachusetts commissioner of elementary and secondary education, is “very concerned” about this year’s MCAS reading scores in the early grades, he said in a telephone press conference Wednesday. In addition, he said the Department of Elementary and Secondary Education is investigating “anomalies” in math test results for 10th graders at Boston English High School.

But he said he is “very pleased” with overall results on the 2015 Massachusetts Comprehensive Assessment System tests. The state released district-by-district and individual school results Thursday.

The district and school results showed that “most have either improved or held their own,” Chester said. That’s in line with the statewide results released Monday, which also included partial results from PARCC, the alternative test that Massachusetts is currently considering as a replacement for MCAS.

Although Boston English sophomores showed improvement in English, with 33 percent more of them than last year scoring proficient or higher, Chester said the state was not releasing math scores for those students because “I saw some anomalies on the math side that I want to review before we release them.” He said he had “no indication” of cheating but would not comment further before investigating.

Boston Public Schools Superintendent Tommy Chang said in a statement Wednesday night that the district is “cooperating fully” with the state review of the English High scores.

“We have every indication, through our communications with English High School, that the school complied with every testing regulation and that all protocols were properly followed,” Chang said in the statement. “We learned of this matter [Wednesday] and are working with the state and the school to resolve it.”

Chang also expressed concern for the students who took the test as sophomores in the spring. “I have deep concerns,” he said, “that now 11th-grade students do not have MCAS Math results, a required component for graduation."

Update: Boston Mayor Martin J. Walsh addressed the issue Thursday after speaking to the Greater Boston Chamber of Commerce about education initiatives and other issues.

"There are so many good things happening at English, it's unfortunate this is happening," Walsh said. "But we're going to work with the state to see what the story is and get a resolution on it."

Across all Boston public schools, according to a BPS statement, 10th-grade math results improved, but “the scores are not rising as rapidly as the proficiency rates for English Language Arts.”

BPS students district-wide tested at 67 percent proficiency in math, 3 percentage points better than in 2014. In English language arts, or ELA, meanwhile, 82 percent of BPS sophomores scored proficient or better, up 6 points from last year.

Both BPS and Chester highlighted figures showing that the so-called achievement gap between white students and students of color is narrowing. In Boston’s 10th grades, the BPS statement said, the achievement gap in ELA shrank by about 8 percentage points.

While Chester noted this progress, he said schools need to continue to work on narrowing the gap.

“I’d be the last one to tell you that I’m complacent about that,” he said. “The gaps are large. But the good news is that the gaps are smaller than they were in the past.”

He also returned several times to what he called “pretty flat” results in reading proficiency for young students over the past nine years.

“I’m very concerned about our reading ELA scores across the board in the early grades,” Chester said. “When you look back over the last decade, there hasn’t been much change in those results. So that worries me a lot.”

He said the state is “actively working on that,” with a group led by Education Secretary James Peyser and Nonie K. Lesaux, a Harvard education professor whose research focuses on literacy.

This latest release includes only MCAS scores, not results on the PARCC test being developed by the Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers. The statewide results did include some PARCC scores, but only for students who took the test on computers – about 60 percent of all those taking PARCC.

The results for PARCC tests taken with paper and pencil will take longer to compile, Chester said. He tentatively set the end of October for the release of full statewide PARCC results, with individual school results not coming until mid-November.

As a result, the state did not release so-called accountability figures for individual schools, nor did it highlight districts that made substantial gains or losses, as it has in previous years. In addition, the lack of complete results for all schools and all districts makes it more difficult to compare this year’s results with earlier ones, or to make definitive comparisons within this year's scores.

“This is a complicated year for the release of these results,” Chester said, “because we’re going to be releasing results from two different assessments.”

Nevertheless, he expressed confidence that the state had developed some “pretty sophisticated statistical processes” that would make accurate year-to-year comparisons possible, whether the state switches to PARCC or stays with MCAS.

This year’s accountability results will probably not be released until late November, Chester said. That would be after the planned Nov. 17 decision on whether to make the switch to PARCC.

“There’s no question that it’s not ideal to wait a couple months before we have the full set of data,” Chester said. “But this was a very purposeful tradeoff,” which allowed districts to choose whether to test PARCC this year.

The decision will come from the state board of education, after Chester makes his recommendation. Pressed for his opinion, he said, “That’s what I’m working on.”

He said MCAS “has been an absolutely critical component” of efforts to improve education in Massachusetts, but “we’ve designed the PARCC test, along with other states, to be a next-generation test.  We need to make a decision as to whether it’s measured up.”