Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

5 Questions With

5 Questions With 'The Prize' Author Dale Russakoff

Then-Newark Mayor Cory Booker, left, and Mark Zuckerberg, center, CEO of Facebook, listen as N.J. Gov. Chris Christie talks about schools and Zuckerberg's donation of $100 million to help Newark public schools, on Sept. 25, 2010. (Rich Schultz/AP)
Then-Newark Mayor Cory Booker, left, and Mark Zuckerberg, center, CEO of Facebook, listen as N.J. Gov. Chris Christie talks about schools and Zuckerberg's donation of $100 million to help Newark public schools, on Sept. 25, 2010. (Rich Schultz/AP)

When Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg announced on "Oprah" in 2010 that he was donating $100 million to the city of Newark to improve its schools, longtime Washington Post reporter Dale Russakoff decided to follow along and see what happened next. Over the next four years, she talked with teachers, parents, students, administrators, politicians, donors -- just about every major figure in the story, in Newark and beyond -- to build a deeply researched, nuanced and thoughtful report.

The result, her book "The Prize," has just been published to widespread acclaim. In it, Russakoff details the missteps and controversies that plagued the reformers from the beginning -- starting, perhaps, with their decision to announce the gift on national television before telling anyone in Newark about it. Even with an additional $100 million in matching funds, the largesse seems to have done shockingly little to improve the quality of Newark's public schools.

Anyone who's interested in how to improve urban schools -- and how not to -- will find a wealth of information and insight in "The Prize." By focusing deeply on one city's issues, the book illuminates many of the problems that all cities face.

Dale Russakoff, author of "The Prize."
Dale Russakoff, author of "The Prize."

Russakoff sat down recently with Learning Lab to discuss her book and what she learned in reporting it. An edited version of that conversation follows.

The Newark schools had $200 million to spend, and yet by the end of your story it seems that too little has changed. What do you think they could have done differently to get better results?

I think that they had a fixed idea of how to do it, and I think they thought it was all about fixing the systems and not about addressing what the needs are in the classroom. In fact there was an email very early in the process, when they were all communicating about this gift, and it said, “MZ’s money is not going to the classroom.”

And it was just a given. Because that would be a waste -- that would go down a rathole, so let’s fix the systems. And consultants can figure out everything else.

What they were doing was kind of from the top down. They wanted to change the system and create a perfect system to create a model that could then be transferred to cities across the country. And I think that that’s trying to figure out “How do you fix the whole system?” without thinking about children.

Although you note that most people on all sides had good intentions, what made it so difficult for them to work together productively?

They actually came to Newark with an idea that because the system was in such disrepair and so dysfunctional that the people in the district didn’t know what they were doing or didn’t know how to improve education. What they came in with was the idea “We have to fix this,” and, in effect, to the people of Newark, “We have to fix you.”

And I think that was not only rude and insulting, it wasn’t smart -- because there are so many people in the schools who are gifted and who continue to try every day, in spite of being trapped in a failing system. And those are the people who are dying to have a chance to fix the system.

Had those people been involved, I think that they would have had better ideas for what needed to be done. And they also would have been able to speak to the whole community about why this is important, as opposed to the community feeling like these are foreigners, these are aliens who’ve come to try to do something to us rather than with us.

I think that’s been a real problem in the education reform movement. And I think there are people in the reform movement who know that and are trying to change that and trying to make this more of a bottom-up, as opposed to a top-down, movement. Because the recognition is that if you do this to people, no matter what happens, when you’re gone, it won’t be sustained anyway. So what have you accomplished?

[Zuckerberg’s gift] was announced on “Oprah,” and nobody in Newark knew about it before Oprah’s national audience knew about it. This was this revolution that was coming to the schools, but the parents of the children in the schools didn’t know anything about it.

I wasn’t in the city the day that came out, but I certainly heard a lot about it as soon as I got there. Within days I went to Newark to do some interviews, and I was just eating in a diner downtown, and I asked the waitress, who looked like she might be a parent, and she said, “What is it that all these billionaires want with our mayor?” You know, why are billionaires always circling around our mayor? And I was so surprised, because I expected her to say “Oh, I’m so excited, this is great, I can’t wait to see what’s going to happen in my child’s school,” but no. It was suspicion immediately and wariness.

If you look at what happened in Washington, D.C., after [schools chancellor] Michelle Rhee left, Kaya Henderson, who’s now the chancellor there, spent an entire year going through a very intensive input process with the community when she wanted to close [20] schools. And that process was websites, meetings, meetings at night, meetings on weekends, to make sure everybody could come.

And then just sitting down and thinking with community members: How could we do this differently? Maybe we shouldn’t close this school because it serves a particular function in this neighborhood; maybe you want to think about consolidating it with another school. Anyway, over the course of the year they made very significant changes based on the input. [Henderson ultimately reduced the number of closings to 15.]

I don’t think anybody was happy that schools were closing, but there was no, you know, uprising over it. People felt that they had been heard. And also that process educated everyone to accept that this really is something that we have to go through. We do have to close some schools.

In Newark, it was done as just such a thunderbolt being hurled at the people that all they did was fight back. There was no chance to really even process “Why is this necessary?” because they just had complete suspicion of the people who told them it was necessary. So there was just a complete fracturing of trust that was never, ever regained, ever. Trust is a very precious thing. And you don’t just assume that you have it, because if you do, you’ve lost it already.

How do you think the shifting balance of district schools and charter schools affects students and teachers in both kinds of school?

Well, it seems like kids in charter schools benefit from that. In Newark the charter schools do outperform the district schools. If you look at New Jersey statewide, that’s not true. But Newark does have a cadre of charter schools that are getting better results than the district schools -- in some cases way better results. So those kids seem to be doing very well.

And those schools are very stable, in that they know what funding they’re going to get per pupil; they get it, they plan for it, and from year to year they know what their staff is going to be, they know which teachers they’re going to have, which support staff, everything. Whereas the district schools -- every year there’s a budget crisis now.

Because as the children leave for charters -- and in a city that’s not growing, there’s no extra kids coming in, no extra money coming in -- they’re constantly closing and consolidating schools, laying off staff, excessing teachers; thousands of kids move from one school to the next. And so it’s a very unstable environment.

And so I think that the kids in the district schools in general -- the test scores, for what they’re worth, show that kindergarten through eighth-grade scores have gone down over the last five years, not up.

You spent more than four years researching this book. What are the biggest lessons you learned from observing an urban school system in such depth?

One thing that I think is really a problem -- I mean, there are so many problems -- but particularly in a community like Newark, where there’s just so much disruption in kids’ lives every day, is that there needs to be a way of following kids from one grade to the next.

Like the boy in the book, Alif, where they got him, really for the first time in his life, to apply himself and to see some success, and then he went to high school, where nobody really had an understanding of what his needs were. And he was so subject to just giving up, and when he didn’t get the support that he desperately needed and the attention that he had gotten before, he just completely -- just plummeted. He didn’t fall through the cracks, he plummeted through the cracks.

These kids -- there have just been terrible, terrible crises that these kids have been dealing with. You know, there’s a kid in the class whose father was murdered in October and he just -- he can’t sit up. He just has to put his head on the desk. And another kid who’s got another kind of issue, and he’s constantly out in the hall because he can’t sit still. And you have one teacher in the classroom trying to deal with all of that. And one social worker in the whole school, who can’t possibly support this.

And I know that the system is overwhelmed, but it seems like one of the things that’s really desperately needed is that kind of predictability and consistency. And just an ability to look at kids one kid at a time. And keep that focus.

And again that’s an issue of having more resources at the school level, some people who can really do that. Kids who have special needs have an IEP, and that’s supposed to travel with them. But everybody needs something that travels with them.

The other thing, merit pay was such a critical point for the reformers here, that we have to have merit pay for the teachers. But universally the teachers I talked to said they would much rather have a good principal and a good working environment than merit pay any day.

Because that was something that wasn’t at all a given in Newark. There were a lot of principals who were almost tyrants, and they bullied teachers and they picked favorites. And a couple of the [reorganized] schools where they got new principals, the way they talked about just the much more positive environment, that they would choose that any day over merit pay. Because, you know, the other drives you insane.

And I guess the other thing, in reforming school districts, is that education is, I think, an ecosystem, and everything you do has consequences somewhere else. And most of them are unintended consequences. And it feels like the education movement so far -- and I think it may be changing -- but so far has just thought of charter schools as a good in themselves and not thought through the consequences for the district schools, where the majority of kids are.

Actually, one scholar in the education reform movement whom I interviewed said that she thought this was something that really needed to change. And she said that we need to have a Pottery Barn rule -- “You broke it, you bought it” -- for people who advocate disruptive reforms.

If you had $200 million to spend on a district like Newark’s, how would you spend it?

The main problem in Newark -- and I would think in cities full of poverty and violence -- is that there’s not enough money at the classroom level and the school level to deal with the issues kids bring to school every day, to support the teachers as they try to reach those kids, to just create support within the school for kids who have emotional problems, kids who have difficulty focusing.

If I could have done it all myself, I think I would have started out having almost like a forensic audit of the school system and try to understand: Where is the money going, at the central office level? And then figure out how to get much more of that money into the schools. And then I think I would have spent my time training principals to spend that money strategically. Because if you just give a principal a much bigger budget, you can’t guarantee that something’s going to come of that.

But I have seen in some of the schools, where principals really understood the needs of the neighborhood and the needs of the kids and the families and what it was going to take almost holistically to get each child enough support to learn – because even if you have the best teacher in the classroom you have a lot of kids who aren’t able to focus, or they may be so far behind academically that they can’t keep up – and so with extra staff and more support, I think you can do a whole lot more.

I’m not saying you can overcome poverty. But I think this argument, like, “Do you have to solve poverty before you improve schools?” I think you don’t have to solve it, but you have to plan to deal with the consequences of poverty. And there was no planning for that.

And so I think that would be my focus. I think I would try to figure out how to streamline the system, get the money to the buildings and train the principals to think strategically about how to build a system within the school that addresses the kids’ needs.