Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

Education Commissioner Recommends 'Next-Generation MCAS' For State Test

Updated November 12, 2015, 4:58 pm

For the next Massachusetts standardized test, Mitchell Chester has picked "Door No. 3" - a blend of the two tests students took last spring.

Rather than choosing either MCAS, the standardized test Massachusetts students have used for 18 years, or PARCC, the test some districts have been piloting for two years, the state's commissioner of elementary and secondary education recommended Thursday that Massachusetts should instead combine elements of the two tests to create a new, "next-generation MCAS."

"I am recommending to the Board that we begin work on a next-generation, computer-based MCAS assessment program," Chester wrote in his recommendation to the state board of education, which will vote on the final decision Nov. 17. "This new test will build on the best elements of both PARCC and MCAS and will allow us to retain final control over our test content, testing policies, and test administration procedures."

His recommendation is significant both for the state and for PARCC, where Chester chairs the governing board and is in charge of developing and promoting PARCC, along with other states. He released it on the same day that the consortium announced it would now allow states to buy just parts of the test and to use their own vendor, rather than being locked into one test administered exclusively by Pearson.

"I'm glad to see that the commissioner basically recommended that Massachusetts should develop what I would call sort of MCAS 2.0," said Gov. Charlie Baker, "which means we set our own terms, we build our own test, and we do what we think makes sense for the kids here in the Commonwealth."

The commissioner's recommendation followed months of speculation on which option he would choose, but it did not come as much of a surprise. After singing PARCC's praises for months, in recent weeks Chester moved to a decidedly different tune. He said as much in a telephone press conference Thursday.

"I don't think that today's recommendation is out of the blue," Chester said. "I think that it evolves from conversations over the last two months," including an Oct. 20 education board meeting in which he floated the idea of an "MCAS 2.0."

Chester cited his desire to retain state control over the assessment while still using elements of the tests developed by PARCC as a cost-effective way of updating MCAS, which he said "has reached a point of diminishing returns."

Others, like Sandra Stotsky, former senior associate education commissioner and professor emerita at the University of Arkansas, are similarly concerned about control. She says the commissioner's recommendation does not give any control over testing to parents and teachers.

"I am not impressed with the commissioner's recommendations because they are too airtight in retaining commissioner and department control of state tests," said Stotsky. "The department is still in control. What we may have, essentially, is PARCC in disguise."

The PARCC consortium once contained 24 states and the District of Columbia. Most have abandoned PARCC, citing politics, cost or technology hurdles. This spring, just seven states and D.C. are slated to give the test.

"There were certainly concerns raised about the sustainability and the viability of PARCC," Chester said in the press call. "In part my recommendation is designed to make sure that we're independent [of PARCC]. ... We can walk away at any time. We own the development that's been done in the past several years."

Under Chester's recommendation for Massachusetts, districts that gave PARCC in spring 2015 would do so again this year. Districts that gave MCAS could stay with it or move to PARCC.

All districts would use the new test in spring 2017, except that MCAS would continue for 10th-graders as a high school graduation requirement until at least the class of 2019 (who will take it in spring 2017). PARCC results would not affect schools' accountability ratings until 2017. And Chester recommended that the state commit to having all districts administer the new test online by 2019.

Chester also recommended that Massachusetts remain an "active member" of the PARCC consortium. And he said Massachusetts should contract with its own vendor, whether Pearson or another company, rather than continuing to work with Pearson through PARCC.

"Because we will be contracting with our own testing vendor, we will have the flexibility to leave the consortium at any time," writes Chester.

Chester said he did not have an estimate of the cost of developing a new test, but acknowledged it will require increased spending from the state's assessment budget.

It's these costs of coming up with an entirely new test that concern some like Jason Williams of the group Stand for Children Massachusetts.

"It is our hope that Tuesday does not come and go with us having a lack of clarity and explicitness to what the plan is over the next two to three years," Williams told the WBUR newsroom.

Chester predicted that "a large proportion" of the PARCC items already developed could be used in the next-generation MCAS. Although that test -- which he suggested in the call could continue to be called "MCAS" -- would contain elements of both PARCC and the original MCAS, he stressed that it would be a smoothly "integrated" mix of the two.

"We want to create an assessment in 2017 that doesn't look like a patchwork quilt," Chester said. "This is not about a compromise per se" between proponents of the two tests.

The Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers (PARCC) tests are aligned with Common Core standards and have been piloted in Massachusetts schools for the past two years. Massachusetts Comprehensive Assessment System (MCAS) tests have been used in Bay State schools since 1998.

U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan, in town Thursday morning, said he had faith in any decision made by Massachusetts education officials.

"Historically Massachusetts was ahead of most states. MCAS was easily one of the better assessments going forward, but I think Massachusetts, like many states, is struggling to get to the right place," Duncan said. "I have every confidence Massachusetts will move in the right direction."

Tommy Chang, superintendent of Boston Public Schools, said in a statement that he looks forward to "working closely" with the department and the commissioner to develop the new assessments.

“He should know that I am personally committed to offering any support that DESE may need,” Chang said.

WBUR's Louise Kennedy contributed to this report.