Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

Guest Commentary: Boston Can Lead The Way To Closing The Achievement Gap

By Ayele Shakur

Reaction to the recent release of statewide MCAS scores shows why we need to change how we think about student achievement – at least in Boston public schools.

Education officials and newspaper headlines touted the narrowing of the “achievement gap” between Black and Hispanic students and white students on MCAS scores. While this progress should be celebrated, there is still a 15-point gap between Black and Latino students and their white and Asian peers in 10th-grade English language arts. The gap in math is even greater: 29 points for Black students and 26 points for Latinos. These gaps can be seen at every grade level and even persist when socioeconomic status is factored in. Boston is a majority-minority city. What does its future hold when so many students of color are failing?

This past summer, the Boston School Committee created an Opportunity and Achievement Gap Task Force to examine systemwide policies, programs and practices designed to eliminate achievement and opportunity gaps in Boston schools and to recommend improvements to the Boston School Committee and Superintendent Tommy Chang.

It’s not the first time that Boston’s education officials have taken steps to close the achievement gap. In 2006, the School Committee approved a comprehensive Achievement Gap Policy. But two things make this new effort different. First, the political stars have aligned so that this work has the strong backing of both a new school superintendent and a new mayor. Second, the task force is not merely focused on the achievement gap. As its name suggests, it is also focused on closing the opportunity gap.

Some of the areas that need improvement are easy to point to, such as entry into the Advanced Work Class program. Right now in Boston, students take a test in the fourth grade that determines their future. It’s unlikely that these 10-year-olds comprehend the high-stakes nature of the test – but it’s also likely that many of their parents do not realize it either.

Those who score well are tracked into the Advanced Work Class program, which puts them on a path to get into the city’s elite high schools: Boston Latin School, Boston Latin Academy, and the John D. O’Bryant School of Mathematics and Science. While students do take a second admissions exam for entry into the elite high schools, that one test in the fourth grade is the only entry point into the advanced tracking program that holds students to a higher standard and gives them the more rigorous instruction that will better prepare them for the high school entrance exam.

As Superintendent Chang noted in his 100-day plan, we should have high expectations for all of our fourth graders, yet our current practice chokes off opportunity for many students before their 11th birthday.

Other areas for improvement might be found in places that are less obvious, such as transportation. Some students spend nearly four hours a day on buses getting to and from school. Do we really believe that these children have the same opportunities for study and achievement as those who can get to a quality school in 15 minutes or less?

The Boston School Committee’s ambitious attempt to examine current practices and lay out steps for improving student achievement has high stakes not just in Boston but for urban districts around the country. Despite its many challenges, Boston is considered to be one of the best urban school districts in the nation. In 2006, after being a finalist the previous five years, the district won the prestigious Broad Prize for Urban Education, which singles out urban school districts that are making the greatest improvements in student achievement while reducing achievement gaps among ethnic and racial groups and across socioeconomic categories. Test scores from the National Assessment of Educational Progress show that Boston Public School students of all races match or outperform their peers in other urban districts.

Many of Boston’s innovations have been adopted by other districts. Perhaps the best example is Parent University, a program that teaches parents how to advocate for their children’s educational needs at school and support their studies at home. Launched in 2009, the program is largely credited with helping three schools — John F. Kennedy School in Jamaica Plain, William Blackstone Elementary in the South End and Roxbury’s Orchard Gardens K-8 Pilot School -- dramatically improve their students’ math and language proficiency and get off the state’s “turnaround list” of underperforming schools. Parent University is now a national model; educators in Ohio and Baltimore have implemented similar programs. If Boston succeeds with an opportunity/achievement gap policy, it could have a similar ripple effect in urban school districts across the country.

Leaders in Boston are poised to implement change and innovation in our schools in ways we have not seen in recent memory. If we succeed, the opportunities that will open up for students in Boston and elsewhere hold the potential to be life-changing and profound.

Ayele Shakur is the executive director of BUILD Greater Boston, chair of the Education Committee of the Boston NAACP and a co-chair of the Boston School Committee’s Opportunity and Achievement Gap Task Force.