Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

For Education Reform, Activists Turn To Ballot Initiatives

Updated December 3, 2015, 10:08 a.m.

BOSTON -- Education could be a red-hot topic on the 2016 Massachusetts ballot, with possible ballot questions on Common Core and charter schools.

On Wednesday, two groups hoping to shift the future of Massachusetts education submitted signatures calling for the ballot questions to the secretary of state's office.

One question would ask voters to reject the Common Core education standards and restore the state's previous standards. The other would ask voters to expand the number of charter schools allowed in Massachusetts.

Groups need to submit at least 64,750 certified voter signatures. If enough signatures are approved by the secretary of state, the questions will be sent to the Legislature for review in January, bringing the questions one step closer to appearing on the November 2016 ballot.

Adding Charter Schools

The charter school ballot initiative, if successful, would allow the state to license up to 12 new charter schools every year, beyond existing caps. Priority would go to charters in the state's lowest-performing 25 percent of school districts, or about 70 districts.

In a statement, the group behind the charter school ballot question said they exceeded the number of signatures needed.

“As we talk with voters across the Commonwealth, support for equal access to public charter schools is strong,” Beth Anderson, Massachusetts Charter Public Schools Association president, said in a statement. Anderson is also founder and CEO of Phoenix Charter Academy Network.

Massachusetts currently has 83 charter schools, with about 34,000 students in all. In May, the state identified 37,000 students on waitlists to get into charters, although critics say the real number is lower.

Critics also say charters erode public school systems by taking dollars originally destined for the roughly 922,000 Massachusetts students in public school districts. According to a WBUR analysis of state data, districts paid charter schools $441 million in the 2014-2015 school year. The state reimbursed the districts just $71 million.

Under current laws, the state may direct up to 9 percent of district student spending to fund seats at charter schools. In low-performing school districts, the state can direct up to 18 percent of spending to charters before spending is capped.

The ballot question would not eliminate the current charter school cap, but rather would create schools in addition to the ones allowed by the cap.

"It is a Trojan mouse," said Barbara Madeloni, president of the Massachusetts Teachers Association, the state's largest teachers union. "It looks potentially small, but they could go in based on this ballot initiative, and whole districts could be charterized in one fell swoop."

She's confident the ballot measure can be beaten, but says, if approved, it would hold grave consequences.

"It is designed to eat away at public education and leave us with a privatized system over the years," said Madeloni.

Others don't agree. Massachusetts Business Alliance for Education president Linda Noonan says an increase in charters would provide choice for parents.

"I think anything that helps improve options for families and that provides high-quality education is important," said Noonan. "Certainly allowing charter schools to meet the demand for what they have to offer."

The ballot question follows a lawsuit to lift the Massachusetts charter cap and legislation filed by Gov. Charlie Baker to expand the number of charter schools in the state. Both are in their early stages.

Ending Common Core

While Common Core standards have met with both praise and criticism since state education officials voted to adopt them in 2010, this is the first time a ballot question has been attempted as a tool to move away from them.

Donna Colorio, chairperson of the End Common Core MA ballot initiative, says under Common Core students are being "dumbed down" compared to earlier standards.

"The pre-Common Core standards were the best in the country, so now we've adopted inferior standards," said Colorio. "Our kids are now experiments of a very bad experiment."

In the past decade, Massachusetts has historically ranked at the top of national education rankings. Colorio says her group delivered 80,000 signatures in support of the ballot initiative, well over the required amount.

Common Core proponents say the standards prepare students to learn the skills needed for college and careers.

"I do believe that the Common Core has incredible potential to transform teaching and learning and more importantly, serve as a powerful tool to close persistent opportunity and achievement gaps," Boston Public Schools Superintendent Tommy Chang said in a statement. "We should not give up on this effort."

Currently, Massachusetts' curriculum frameworks and standardized tests reflect Common Core standards. State education officials last month approved the creation of a new test, which will be based largely on the Common Core-aligned PARCC test.

Other groups submitted signatures for ballot initiatives on topics including marijuana legalization, animal welfare and a 4 percent income tax for millionaires.