State Declares Madison Park High School 'Underperforming'

Updated December 9, 2015, 5:23 p.m.
Massachusetts education officials on Wednesday designated a long-troubled Boston vocational high school as "underperforming," as they released annual state accountability results for schools across the state.
Madison Park Technical Vocational High School is the only newly identified underperforming school this year, a shift from last year when six schools were given that status. There are 15 schools in total labeled as underperforming.
The distinction is based on tests scores, plus graduation and dropout data.
The vast majority of Boston Public Schools (BPS) did not see their status change. Three BPS schools significantly improved. Madison Park is one of five Boston schools that saw their accountability status decline.
Boston Superintendent Tommy Chang said the district is aware that Madison Park has long been underperforming and that the rating could help "galvanize" a plan already in place to vastly improve the school.
"Academic performance isn't where it needs to be, graduation performance isn't where it needs to be, and it is our collective responsibility to do better," Chang told WBUR at BPS headquarters on Wednesday. "The support of Madison Park is one of our key projects in the 100-day plan."
Kevin McCaskill, Madison Park executive director, said in the same meeting that he sees the school as ripe for change.
"We are going to be committed to doing the work, we understand the task at hand, the past situation," said McCaskill.
The downgrade hits Madison Park after a chaotic 2014-2015 school year. The vocational school was still hiring teachers as the school year began, many students had no schedules or room assignments for weeks, and leadership changes ensued until a Mccaskill took the helm in July. The test scores that influenced the state's decision revealed Friday took place in the spring.
State education commissioner Mitchell Chester said the underperforming rating does not signal a "no confidence vote" in the new Madison Park leadership or Superintendent Chang. In a call with reporters, he said the rating is due to reviewing the school's turnaround plan at the start of this school year.
"I did not get the sense that the turnaround plan that had been developed a year earlier was something that any of us had any confidence in at this point of time," Chester said. He says the rating signals "a recognition that, despite a lot of goodwill, Madison Park continues to languish."
Some Madison Park teachers have raised concerns they will be scapegoated for a situation they say they had no control over.
Of the other 14 schools in Boston, Holyoke, Lawrence, New Bedford, Salem, and Springfield that remain in underperforming status, state officials say the schools have shown some, but not sufficient, improvements.
Still, the accountability results contain some good statewide news. Four schools have now exited underperforming status after successfully turning around student achievement. The schools are in Lawrence, Springfield and Worcester.
"Some of the greatest effort, some of the strongest improvement that we're seeing, in fact, is found in some of our turnaround schools," Chester said. "I give that credit to our educators, both our teachers and our administrators, as well as the families who are willing to take on the kinds of reforms and changes that raise expectations."
Of the more than three dozen schools that the state designated underperforming in 2010 and 2011, the majority have now exited that status. Officials also commend 45 schools for high achievement, strong progress and narrowing proficiency gaps.
Many districts and schools saw no change in their accountabilty levels from last year. This is in large part due to many of them taking the PARCC assessment last year. The state opted to not decrease a school's accountability levels if they take PARCC.
The roughly 460 schools which received top status are on track to halve their achievement gaps by 2017, said Chester. Thirteen Boston schools were given that distinction this year, including Roxbury's John D. O'Bryant School of Math and Science and East Boston's Samuel Adams Elementary School.
And five districts -- Gloucester, Cambridge, Everett, Mashpee and Nantucket -- join the ranks of districts in which all schools are rated proficient or higher.
"I feel very good about it," Frederick Foresteire, Everett superintendent, said about the recognition.
Gloucester Superintendent Richard Safier credits the district's success to a handful of new practices, including a teaching model which pairs a special education and a regular education teacher together in each classroom.
"It's a matter of getting the right programs in place, the people behind those programs," said Safier. "And, once you have those programs in place, it's about execution and fidelity."
Schools must provide four years of data to be given a measure. More than one-quarter of the state's charter schools did not provide enough data to the state to be given an accountability measure.
Of the 60 charter schools that did, 34 rated as not meeting targets toward narrowing proficiency gaps for students.
WBUR's Delores Handy contributed to this report.
Correction: Due to incorrect information from the state, an earlier version of this article reported that 13 schools other than remain in turnaround status. The correct number is 14. We regret the error.