Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Comment of the Day

Guest Commentary: Please, No PARCC In Disguise

A student works on math problems as part of a trial run of a Common Core-linked test on Feb. 12, 2013. Guest columnist Dolores Wood says Massachusetts should rely on MCAS, not PARCC. (Patrick Semansky/AP)
A student works on math problems as part of a trial run of a Common Core-linked test on Feb. 12, 2013. Guest columnist Dolores Wood says Massachusetts should rely on MCAS, not PARCC. (Patrick Semansky/AP)

By Dolores Wood

Now that the state Board of Education has approved MCAS 2.0, as expected, Massachusetts is going to have to decide how it wants a hybrid test to look and what it should address.

What concerns me most about the latest idea to combine PARCC and MCAS for an MCAS 2.0 is that we could end up with all the confusion of PARCC and none of the assets of the MCAS. Nineteen out of the 24 original PARCC states have dropped the PARCC test during the past few years. Many of these states have declared they found the test's questions to be meaningless and unclear.

Proponents of PARCC claim it is more rigorous than MCAS. But PARCC's "rigor" in English Language Arts has been less of a stimulating challenge and more of a word-mincing exercise, parsing infinitesimal differences between indistinguishable ideas. PARCC is not demanding. It is confusing.

At least the MCAS has a more straightforward presentation and execution. If you can comprehend an excerpt and reply to a question with claim, evidence and reasoning, you can pass the MCAS. To date, every student who attends my classes has found this achievable, from the lowest levels – a second-year ESL student – to the highest honors student.

Generally, you do not have to mince words on the MCAS. Hyperbole is clearly represented as exaggeration; irony is clearly represented as the opposite of what you would expect, etc. There is little quibbling or nitpicking like there is in PARCC, where students find themselves trying to determine whether a wild statement in the reading is "exaggerating the humor" or "pointing out the irony," which can be very similar in some cases.

We are, after all, discussing a high school test. We have the SAT and numerous AP tests to increase the rigor into the college arena.

Urban students, especially, will rebel when they are being asked to perform an arcane stimulus-response testing ritual. They rebel when they are asked about the structure of a text but are not challenged to produce original ideas of its significance. They feel disrespected. They stop reading mindless exercises and they start wildly clicking answers. No entreaties about ruining their futures will deter them. Their reasoning? The deck is stacked against them and so why try, or they can't fail if they don't try.

On the other hand, urban students will make sincere attempts at claim-evidence-reasoning on open response and long composition when they are asked to grapple with problems to be solved or profound thoughts to interpret. I have received many insightful and well-written essays on MCAS topics such as "For Some Pain is Orange," about seeing the world through different eyes, an article on synesthesia in Smithsonian Magazine. My students have produced  many thoughtful essays about character development from excerpts of Austen's “Pride and Prejudice,” figurative language from Dickens’ “Hard Times” and setting from Conrad's “Heart of Darkness,” to name a few. It is wrong to say there is a lack of rigor here.

Since our destiny is to be MCAS 2.0 whether we like it or not, I hope state education officials will put themselves in the shoes of those of us teaching these students and consider the goals we are trying to achieve. Fussy arcane questions about literary devices and ambiguous shades of meaning are not going to tell us what we need to know about our high school students and whether they should graduate. We need to know that they have the foundations to proceed and the skills to make the most out of their education, that they can find their true calling and meet their true purpose.

MCAS gives us that. There also are many other exciting ideas for assessing student knowledge with portfolios and/or progressive stages of assessments instead of one, all-or-nothing, high-stakes test.

Massachusetts has achieved the nation's top spot in education and ranked among the short list of the world's finest seats of learning without a confusing, meaningless, computerized exercise. We all want to assess what the students know and how we can help them to the next step.

"The function of education is to teach one to think intensively and to think critically. ... Intelligence plus character – that is the goal of true education," said Martin Luther King, Jr.  A robotest is the opposite of that direction. Please don't take us backward with an MCAS 2.0 that is just PARCC in disguise.

Dolores Wood teaches English and ESL in Boston Public Schools.