Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

State May Shut Down Dorchester Charter School

BOSTON -- The Massachusetts Board of Elementary and Secondary Education will consider closing a Dorchester charter school, after years of poor academic results that have shown little improvement.

Education Commissioner Mitchell Chester recommended closing Dorchester Collegiate Academy Charter School in a Dec. 9 memorandum, two years after the board placed the school on probation. The board will vote on revoking the school's charter in its January meeting.

"Over the course of the school’s history," writes Chester, "with a few exceptions, [Dorchester Collegiate] has been the lowest performing charter school in Boston."

Chester cites the school's low test scores, high attrition rates and lackluster enrollment as reasons to close the seven-year-old charter school, which serves about 200 students in grades 4-8.

A statement from the school says Dorchester Collegiate staff members are “disappointed and surprised by the Commissioner’s recommendation.” They say the school provides a "holistic education" for students who may not thrive in traditional academic environments.

"For example, in the current academic year, over 45% of our students require therapeutic counseling -- with 16% requiring intensive therapeutic counseling 3 or more times per week," the statement reads.

Still, more than half of Dorchester Collegiate students scored below proficient on 2015 MCAS tests in science, math and English language arts. The state reports a 30.2 percent attrition rate at Dorchester Collegiate for the 2014-2015 school year.

Bob Flynn, Dorchester Collegiate headmaster, says much attrition can be credited to factors beyond academics. He says some families left the school when it was placed on probation, others when the school scaled back plans to expand to higher grade levels.

“We had parents leave because they were looking for a school that went through high school,” said Flynn.

If the board votes to close the school, it would be a rare, but not unheard-of, move. As the sole charter school authorizer in Massachusetts, the board has the right to revoke a school's charter.

The education board has only ever voted to close 12 charter schools for performance-related reasons.

"In the majority of these instances, failure to demonstrate academic success was a key factor in the closure decision," writes Chester.

If the board approves Chester's recommendation, the school will close its doors in June 2016.