Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Comment of the Day

Guest Commentary: It’s Time to Stop Hiding Behind Graduation Rates

High school graduation is a milestone worth celebrating, writes guest columnist Nicholas Donohue, but schools need to do more to prepare students for what comes next. (Dave Herholz/Flickr)
High school graduation is a milestone worth celebrating, writes guest columnist Nicholas Donohue, but schools need to do more to prepare students for what comes next. (Dave Herholz/Flickr)

By Nicholas C. Donohue

This month, tens of thousands of high school seniors across the state are returning home to the thrill of a college acceptance letter, heralding an important path toward a successful and prosperous life. As we celebrate the achievement these well-deserving students worked so hard to earn, we should also ask ourselves if we are doing everything we can to make sure current and future graduates are completely prepared for this important next step.

It is easy to point to high school seniors graduating at an all-time high rate of 82 percent nationally and say that we are making great strides across the country in guiding students into rewarding futures. And an 87 percent rate in Massachusetts might even strengthen the argument to suggest that we are leading the way in doing so.

Yet while higher graduation rates are positive news, it is important to keep our eyes on the real prize. Late last year, The New York Times reported that these peaks in graduation rates overshadow an alarming truth: Many high school graduates are not fully ready for college or career. These questions over the value of a high school diploma echo the results of a recent survey conducted among high school students nationwide, which found that less than half of them felt positive about their college or career readiness.

Although graduation rates are up, as many as half of those in New England who enter post-secondary education are not fully ready for college-level work. As a result, many students require remedial classes to strengthen basic math and reading skills before they move on to college courses, costing them both time and money and too often acting as a slippery slope to non-completion. We are cheating our children and ourselves by continuing to operate under the illusion that a diploma alone is proof they have been adequately prepared to succeed after high school.

The realities of our modern world make it clear that for our society to progress, our young people need to be truly ready for success in post-secondary education. For these reasons, the Nellie Mae Education Foundation is embracing an ambitious goal:  at least 80 percent college and career readiness for all New England students, including traditionally underserved populations, by 2030. Our Big Goal Initiative aims to reshape public education through key investments in student-centered approaches to learning. This innovative approach to learning is not restricted to the classroom. It is personalized and engaging, and it allows students to take ownership of their education.

Here in New England, we’ve seen how student-centered approaches can transform secondary education. At Pittsfield Middle High School in New Hampshire, students earn course credit by mastering their subjects, rather than just fulfilling traditional classroom hours. They intern with local businesses, where learning occurs outside of the classroom; and they own their educational progress by leading parent-teacher conferences. Previously one of New Hampshire’s bottom-five performing districts, Pittsfield has not only increased test scores but increased college aspirations among its students.

In Massachusetts, Revere High School underwent a similar transformation, becoming a national model for equity in education in just two years. With a population comprising 60 percent students of color and 80 percent low-income students, the school increased achievement among those historically marginalized in our education system. At Revere, students run their classes, initiating substantive dialogue about the topics they choose to study. The use of iPads allows them to connect with teachers online, and many receive internship credit for their work at the school’s “genius bar,” where they provide help for the less technologically savvy.

Student-centered learning allows us to step out from behind graduation rates to help students succeed long after commencement. That is crucial, because the complex skills, critical thinking and specialized training that drive our economy dictate how well prepared young people must be before entering it.

One hundred years ago, you could work hard, show that you could be compliant, and get a good job after graduating from high school. But times have changed. By 2018, 63 percent of all jobs will require some level of postsecondary education and training.

It is time to remodel the pillars of our educational structure so that our students can not only complete their senior year -- but become lifelong learners and full participants in our society. Student-centered approaches can help us do that.

A series of studies commissioned in 2014 by the Nellie Mae Education Foundation found that first-generation college-goers who graduated from a student-centered environment outpaced their peers on state assessments and were more likely than the average student nationally to stay in college. We’ve seen student-centered approaches succeed at schools such as City Arts and Technology High School in San Francisco, which has seen 97 percent of its graduates who enrolled in four-year colleges remain for their fourth year -- a figure that far exceeds the national college persistence rate.

These successes need not be limited to a few, innovative schools. We can ensure success in our communities by equipping younger generations with the knowledge, skills and mindsets necessary to succeed in life even after high school -- but the time to do so is now.

Rather than continuing to hide behind graduation rates, we must all play a part in growing public awareness and demand around student-centered learning and in increasing the tools and resources available to educators and school systems. If we want our society to thrive in the decades to come, we must prepare accordingly. This means focusing on readiness.

Nicholas C. Donohue is the president and CEO of the Nellie Mae Education Foundation, the largest philanthropic organization in New England focused exclusively on education. The foundation works with schools and organizations to implement student-centered learning. You can follow him on Twitter @NickDonohueNMEF.