Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

How Much School Autonomy Is Enough? How Much Is Too Much?

A third of students in Boston Public Schools are already in schools with some degree of autonomy. A report released yesterday says the district should go further, granting more flexibility to more schools.

Dan French, executive director of the Center for Collaborative Education, is one of the authors of the report.

"If schools are going to be held accountable for results, then resources and decision making should be placed in the hands closest to students and parents, and that that is principals and teachers," French said on Radio Boston. "That said, autonomy is not a panacea nor a guarantor of success."

Richard Stutman, head of the Boston Teachers Union, said this is the wrong conversation entirely. And he warned that granting schools more autonomy "will eventually lead to a dissolution of the public school system as we know it."

"We're talking about autonomy. We should be talking about equality, as much as accountability and autonomy," Stutman said.

"I think by favoring autonomous schools, to the extent that they benefit at the expense of non-autonomous schools is a disservice to our students. When I caution about the dissolution of our public schools, I caution about that."

Asked for examples of how added flexibility over budgets and curriculum would help, French said some autonomous high schools now have four long school days with a shorter fifth day, allowing more time for staff development and training. Others have combined English and social studies classes.

But Stutman said schools can already do much of what autonomy offers while remaining under full district control. Modifying a school schedule, like the example French cited, just takes a 55 percent vote of the staff, he said.

"If a principal can't get 55 percent of the staff to vote for it, then the principal doesn't have the support of the staff," Stutman said.

"There are many, many things that can be accomplished on a day-to-day basis without autonomy. I'm not saying autonomy's bad, but I think it's a disservice to say it's responsible for things that can't be done otherwise."

Listen to the full discussion above, or at Radio Boston, and read the full report here.