Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Comment of the Day

Comment of the Day: BPS is "what we have now"

Commenter "BPS Parent" responds to "Jules" on the question of moving out of Boston Public Schools:

I'm a BPS parent of two kids.

BPS is not perfect.

But for many, like myself, it's what we have now, and I, along with thousands of other parents, try to help the school system as best as we can.

We have to do that by battling the BPS, the politicians who ignore my kids, and a lot of rich people with fancy titles who don't want us to notice there are billiions to be off of our kids, and with respect, other parents they've convinced that there's nothing worth fighting for when it comes to the BPS.

They are very wrong. BPS is not perfect, but it's a damn sight better than many of the alternatives. Let's make it better, together, for every kid.

BPS parents are still here, holding a school system accountable is exactly what we have to do, but I think you ignore some of the good things that are happening in BPS now.

With respect, there are a handful of teachers I've known who are not as motivated as they should be, beaten down over years of overwork battling a student population in crippling poverty. But they have been a tiny, tiny minority compared to the teachers I've know over years and years who are amazing people trying to do the best they can while being blamed, doing incredibly hard jobs with next to no money to do it. I know I wouldn't last an afternoon in a class.

There are far too many level 3 schools in BPS, but you know what, there are many level 1 and level 2 schools now too - many facing budget cuts as a direct result of charter seats.

I don't hold it against any other parent their choice of school, but please understand that the way the charters are currently funding directly affect public school funding for the worse, and the more charters open, the worse that will get.

It's not fair.

If it's about choice, what about mine? Or the choice of 75% of all school aged kids in Boston who go to the BPS?

I am sorry that you had a horrible time at BPS, but please don't take away my kids' future because you hold on to your own experiences and that is still the case now. For many they, but for many they are not. In fact, that is the case in many, many charter schools.

If you look at the stats the state's education department reports, almost all charters do not educate English language learners, or kids with special needs anywhere near the same degree the BPS does. In fact, the Federal department of education recently sent a letter to charters reminding them they are obliged to follow civil rights law.

BPS must educate everyone, the charters don't.

Charter expulsion rates and their suspension rates are through the roof. Their graduation rates are scandalous.

If BPS had those types of stats, WBUR would be parroting the Boston Foundation calling for every principal's head. Funny that you never, ever hear any of these bad stories about charters even though it's publicly available on the state's website. Funny the Boston Foundation funds WBUR, and every morning there's Bob Oakes, ignorantly peddling the charter talking points, trying desperately to create a crisis when BPS has been doing a lot of positive things, ignoring completely the conditions in charters schools for their own students. Again, BPS is not perfect, but even the report says they are NOT in crisis...

You talk about going to college. SAT scores in charters are not that great at all, in fact public schools do better. They also do better when it comes to grades in college. In fact, in educating kids in general, 20% of charters have been shown to do better than comparable public schools, 40% do about the same, and the rest? Charters do far worse than comparable public schools. So much for the promise of charters.

Charters have lots of nice looking brochures promising door to door bus service for my kids from one end of Boston to the other (on BPS dime, not their's). They won't mention all the kids they kick out because their English is not that good, or they have special needs, or just aren't good test takers, who all then end up back in the public schools.

If you believe in a "high quality education NOW!" as you say, work to make BPS better, and appreciate that there are many, many positive things going on already in BPS the press, WBUR included, and rich people who've never set foot in my kids' school don't even know about, or worse, don't mention because there's a lot of money to be made by not acknowledging those truths.

Companies shouldn't be trying to make money off the back of kids in public schools, or in charter schools either. A high quality education is a right. You're correct in that of course. But it should be a right for everyone.

If you are 100% behind charters, challenge charters to accept all the students public schools have educate, challenge charters to hire high quality teachers like the BPS does who are nationally certified to actually teach, challenge charters to open up their governance for the public, challenge charters to teach kids not just to be good test takers, challenge charters to graduate more kids instead of kick them back to the BPS, challenge charters to teach kids so they will actually do well in college or technical school. Surely that's what you as a parent think is fair, don't you?

I mean, let's be honest, charters are private schools funded by public dollars who can pick who they educate and who are not accountable to anyone.

Again, I am sorry about your own horrible experiences years ago. But your solution of putting out the fire by burning down the house is not what I think we need to.

Please don't trash my kids' access to a good education in BPS because you mistakenly believe it's a failing system. It has a lot of problems. I know them well, my kids live them every day. But I also know they are happy where they are, and so am I.

Their school is succeeding precisely because parents have chosen to make a go of it, and have put in the energy to turn them as partners with teachers and the BPS. And they are succeeding.

Please don't take that away from us.