Guest Column: Linda Nathan on School Autonomy

Linda Nathan is a nationally recognized educator working in school reform. She is the founding headmaster of Boston Arts Academy and has worked in BPS for 35 years.
In June Boston University announced that Nathan was joining the School of Education to lead a new initiative on developing educational leadership.
Nathan spent the past year working with BPS to study school autonomy. She reflects on her experiences in the guest column below.
A special job came with a singular special request: Get clarity on the issue of autonomy for Boston Public Schools. This was the essence of my assignment for most of a year for the Boston School Superintendent.
So what did autonomy mean? Why does it often get a “bad rap”? Ideally, autonomy comes with increased accountability and includes latitude for a school to make its own management decisions without the constrictions of central office mandates. In most cases, in Boston, autonomous schools often have more flexibility with union contracts.
Such decisions regard budgeting, staffing,governance, curriculum, assessment, professional development, length of school day and calendar. Autonomy is a way to leverage innovative practices and improve student achievement. Charter (and there are many variations of charters including Horace Mann and in-district charters as well as Commonwealth charters which are not part of the Boston Public Schools), Innovation schools and Pilot schools fall into this category.
By 2013, nearly one third of the Boston Public School students attended some type of autonomous school. The issue was at least 30 different autonomous schools in a district of nearly 130 schools. One needed a glossary to understand all of the variations.
My involvement in autonomous schools in Boston begins at the beginning: Fenway High School, the first school to hold a charter in the state. As co-director, we were also the first to give it back in favor of pilot status. In 1998, I founded Boston Arts Academy, one of the first pilot high schools of six running that year.
So as a teacher and a principal for decades, I never saw myself as a “central office” person. Yet Interim Superintendent John McDonough and this Special Advisor focus proved irresistible. My longstanding admiration and respect for John goes back over 30 years.
Several fundamental questions underscored this past year’s work: Is autonomy a necessary, but not sufficient, condition for student success? Should all schools within BPS operate within autonomous structures? How and under what conditions should autonomy be granted? Should autonomy be withdrawn on certain conditions?
For much of the year, I had to clarify that this was a larger study of the impact and role of autonomy for school leaders and their teams across the system. This was not a study about autonomous schools. Our research team wanted to both outline a vision for autonomy for the BPS and analyze how autonomy could be a powerful lever in improving outcomes for all BPS students.
As director and coordinator of the study, I was joined by two amazing organizations from my past work—Education Resource Strategies (ERS) and Center for Collaborative Education (CCE), an organization I co-founded. CCE played an important advocacy role supporting the growth and development of pilot schools, so the research needed to be divided to allow for maximum validity and reliability.
ERS would be in charge of the local study; CCE would be in charge of the national study. The national study examined autonomy in five other urban districts—Los Angles, New York, Baltimore, Denver and Lawrence, MA. – and helped us reflect on what we were learning in Boston. For example, in one of our cross-functional team meetings, we spent much time examining how Denver structured its central office and decision-making processes in comparison to Boston’s.
Our methodology was iterative “action-research.” For example, my first move was to pull together a cross-functional team of approximately 25 individuals – central office personnel, principals and headmasters (of both autonomous and traditional schools), a teacher and a parent.
More parents, teachers and student representation would have been ideal, but as researchers we recognized our limitations both with time and funding. A doctoral student joined me to work with the teacher member to conduct teacher interviews and focus groups—thus ensuring a great deal of teacher voice and opinion in the study.
We interviewed over 100 individuals – school leaders, district leaders, teachers and others. We reviewed existing data and conducted new analysis on student performance, student assignment and budgetary resource allocation.
This was the first time that many members of the cross-functional team had participated in such a rich and varied research project. Another first time was central office and school-based individuals coming together as one to deepen our collective understanding of this area that affected us all.
In fact this new realization about how central office and school-based personnel worked for the same school system was one of our earliest findings. In the current culture, school-based people feel maligned and misunderstood by central-office personnel. Central office personnel are troubled by the lack of alignment and commitment to common goals.
There is often a great divide between the two entities. We needed to address this lack of trust as the ‘elephant in the room.’ Having John McDonough as part of the team certainly helped alleviate distrust and tensions since John engenders trust from almost everyone. We also had skillful facilitation from ERS.
We made a short film about the process of working together (on BPS website). Comments in the video underscore the importance of allowing central and school-based personnel opportunities to tackle important issues together and with equal standing.
Has the study has been successful? It depends on whom you ask. For the autonomous schools, the study helped clarify and crystallize some long-standing tensions that we could then work out during many meetings as a research team with the cross-functional team. We became more aware of how disadvantaged traditional schools were regarding budget and hiring autonomy.
The district quickly managed to provide hiring autonomy for every single BPS school. This is absolutely revolutionary and will have positive effects on school climate, culture and hopefully student achievement for years to come. And most important, the work culminated in a Autonomous Schools Handbook that will be used to train both new autonomous school leaders and their boards and central office personnel.
As a result of the study, much more interest exists among school leaders in pursuing autonomous status (either becoming Innovation Schools or Horace Mann Charter schools). An outgrowth of the study was the establishment of Next Generation Schools for BPS. This is a process, timeline and structure for how schools can gain more autonomy.
This is the first time the BPS central office will offer both support, professional development and a clear structure for schools to make programmatic changes and/or to become autonomous. Again, for the first time, the district can put forward what kind of new schools it would like to see, in what neighborhoods, and with what possible foci—i.e. support for ELL students, or more dual-language schools, or schools that work with overage students.
Given the previous lack of structure and clarity that surrounded the founding and existence of autonomous schools for over 20 years, this is an important advancement. No longer will BPS feel like a “maze with no guidance” (quote from a district official from interviews). Now the district can develop the capacity to evaluate, capture and spread innovation from and between schools. These findings sit as an invitation for implementation by the new BPS superintendent. In all the other districts we studied, a central cross-functional office best implements a portfolio approach to schools.
So, for next year, the Next Generation Schools initiative will be the beginning of such an office. I am also excited that the High School Network (which represents 35 different kinds of high schools) is actually implementing one of the recommendations—to give headmasters the opportunity to select affinity groups as part of their professional development—in lieu of just coming together in a group of 35 leaders each month.
One of the most significant challenges from the study involves finances. Traditional schools have less purchasing power. Changing that paradigm requires a real shift in how central office conceptualizes and then executes budgeting.
The study analyzed how differing rules adversely affect traditional (or non-autonomous schools). We did not have the capacity to deeply analyze resource allocation methodologies in order to recommend improvements. We recommended that BPS decentralize non-core central services and transition to a purchased service model for the remaining non-core services. Implementation will take a radical rethinking of budgeting processes and procedures.
What surprised me most about the study? The difficulty of governance autonomy for autonomous schools. Autonomous schools have more than a School Site Council, an advisory body consisting of teachers, parents/caregivers and often, but not always, community members.
While the School Site Council often plays a critical role with hiring and recommendations about other policies, it has no real “teeth” in terms of school governance. Schools and school leaders and teachers that have chosen to be autonomous have to implement a more complex kind of school governance—one that really thinks about how the school functions in perpetuity.
For some of autonomous schools, the boards have statutory and fiscal repsponsibilities and oversite. School leaders are rarely trained in this area. Few school leadership programs help principals think of themselves as a leader of a not for profit with a board that can and should challenge and can and should be involved—not in micro-managing—but in thinking, implementing, evaluating and voting on policy issues that affect the school and its students. This is not easy.
Here is where we see a schism between how central office thinks about hiring and evaluating its leaders and how truly autonomous schools (and their boards) think about hiring and evaluating their leaders. This area that will require much more attention and work. For BPS to continue to nurture the growth and development of autonomous schools, it must also develop the leadership capacity to head those schools.
BPS can learn and consider the implications of other national models. For example, the
district should include a distinct theory of action about autonomous schools as a means to leverage innovative practices and improve student achievement.
All of the districts studied believed that central offices needed to be re-structured to provide targeted support to schools and groups of schools, and to particularly pay attention to the different kind of support that autonomous schools might need.
All of the districts also grappled, similar to BPS, with how to pair autonomy with accountability. Baltimore, in particular, experimented the most with bounded autonomy. BPS may be moving towards a new system of accountability that will re-introduce the School Quality Review.
This rigorous 3-4 day review of a school, much like the processes of Commonwealth Charter Schools, fell by the wayside recently in BPS. Our study helped to reactivate this – something that will go a long way in helping schools—autonomous and traditional—be clearer and more committed to autonomy with accountability.
When I began the study, I promised to leave BPS a bit better than I found it. I think I accomplished that goal. I transition from 35 years in the BPS to a new position at Boston University as the founder of the Institute for Creative Educational Leadership I hope that the implications and findings of this year long study will continue to enlighten my work and also enrich the work of the Boston Public Schools.