How Does METCO Measure Up To Its Original Goals?
METCO began in 1966 with three guiding principles: to provide enhanced educational opportunities for participating students, reduce the racial isolation of suburban school districts, and to reduce segregation in city schools.
As the program nears 50 years since it's founding, and as we mark 40 years since the Boston busing crisis, we're looking back on how the state's voluntary busing desegregation program has lived up to its original goals, and where it goes in the future.
Living Up To Existing Goals
Of METCO's three original goals, providing "enhanced educational opportunities" has been the most fulfilled. The program has been an academic success story for the students lucky enough to make it off METCO’s waitlist.

WGBH News reports,
The commonwealth’s Executive Office of Education reported a 94 percent four-year high school graduation rate for METCO students in 2011, compared with 85 percent statewide, 64 percent in Boston and 52 percent in Springfield. Of these graduates, 89 percent of METCO students enroll in higher education, compared with 81 percent statewide, 59 percent in Boston and 67 percent in Springfield.
In some cases, METCO students' college attendance rates average above the receiving district’s.
Addressing the racial isolation of Boston's suburbs is METCO's second goal. A district is defined as racially isolated when more than 30 percent of its students are white.
While racial isolation may be pierced by METCO's involvement, the program is far from dramatically affecting any isolation in place.
"When you have participating districts that are 90 percent Caucasian, you may have a district with only 40 or 45 [METCO] students. And the district may have six or seven elementary schools, one or two middle schools, and one high school," said John Shandorf, associate director of METCO.
"If you look at that spread out, you’re only talking about possibly one or two students per classroom."
The third goal -- addressing racial segregation within Boston's schools -- was not remedied by METCO's voluntary busing program.
It took until District Court Judge Arthur W. Garrity’s 1974 order to desegregate Boston public schools by busing to tackle school segregation head on, eight years after METCO's birth.
'People May Not Take Kindly To Telling It Like It Is'
Thirty-seven districts enroll METCO students today, each with a local METCO program that oversees participating students.
Weston METCO had the first external review conducted in 2008, over 40 years after it began accepting bused students. Likewise, Needham had its first external review this year, after participating in METCO for 45 years.
External reviews are not required by the statewide METCO Inc. Reviews are done at the discretion of individual district METCO programs.
David Fuller, former Director of Weston's METCO program has since conducted external reviews for a handful of other METCO programs in the state. Fuller said the lack of program reviews is because many directors maintain an attitude of "if its not broken, why fix it?" when it comes to their programs.
"They may not want the grievances to be aired that we know are there," Fuller said. "People may not take kindly to telling it like it is."
The Needham Times reported on Fuller's findings:
The review found "no overwhelming sign" that METCO students were "thriving academically, socially or emotionally," but did discover "favorable progress" in all three areas.
METCO students have been increasingly enrolling in upper-level courses. Most of that gain, however, has come through honors courses, rather than accelerated or advanced placement courses.
Students in the program seem to thrive at the elementary level but start to fall behind their peers as they pass through middle school and high school.
Both Boston parents and suburban parents were "relieved" that there was documentation available with hard numbers and facts after the reviews occurred, Fuller said.
METCO, The Future, And A Changing City
With Boston rapidly gentrifying, Shandorf, METCO's associate director, sees reasons to expand the program. He hopes for more funding before low-income families, disproportionately families of color, are forced out of the city to more affordable suburbs -- ones without high performing school districts.
When families move out to the suburbs, Shandorf says, many patterns of segregation continue in that context, with communities divided along racial lines and school demographics reflected accordingly.
METCO's directors hope to see a change in the future and their model, with overall academic benefits, replicated outside of Boston.
"When you have this successful program," Shandorf said, "why isn't there an ongoing discussion about how do we not only expand this program in the communities that are currently participating, but why not look at replicating the model?"