Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

Fed. Review Finds Boston Provides Poor Services To English Language Learners

BOSTON -- Nearly five years after a federal investigation prompted Boston's school system to overhaul programs for students who speak limited English, an ongoing federal review obtained by the Boston Globe shows that the school system is still failing to provide those students with an adequate education.

The federal review shows that, in middle school and high school, 49 percent of Boston's students known as English-language learners (ELLs) receive insufficient specialized instruction or none at all. In elementary school, 24 percent of students with language barriers are without adequate specialized instruction.

In some cases, students received some or all of their specialized instruction from teachers who do not hold the proper certifications. Boston schools service about 15,500 ELLs.

The current review stems from an earlier investigation into the public education available to students with limited English skills.

In 2011, the U.S. Department of Justice and the U.S. Department of Education embarked on a joint investigation of Boston's ELL program. The investigation revealed ELL students' civil rights were violated by a serious lack of qualified teachers for ELL students, both in Boston and throughout the state.

That investigation led Massachusetts' Department of Elementary and Secondary Education to create new curriculum standards and assessments, professional development and licensing requirements for teachers of ELL students and administrators.

The current federal review found that Boston still struggles to provide students with appropriate instructional programs.

From the Boston Globe:

Federal agencies have been experiencing great difficulties in determining the extent to which the school system is bringing its programs into compliance, according to the latest review, because Boston has been producing reports riddled with inaccuracies every year.

Although the school system assured the federal agencies in the fall that “it was working doggedly to fix data accuracy issues” and that the December data would be accurate, the agencies found significant discrepancies between the districtwide data and information reported by individual schools, which provided a rosier view.

The agencies said observations by investigators during limited site visits frequently backed up some information in the individual school reports. But the agencies also expressed frustration in the letter that many of the school reports lacked a required signature from the principal, certifying that the data are accurate, and many addendums noted by principals were not provided.

According to the Globe, the school department is already taking measures to address the concerns.

On Monday, the School Department replaced the assistant superintendent in charge of English-language learner education with an in-house attorney who specializes in compliance. Then, on Wednesday night, the School Committee held a private session to discuss the review.

Related: