Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

Report Urges State To Expand METCO

A report released Tuesday by the Pioneer Institute says that METCO deserves better funding. (David Goldman/AP)
A report released Tuesday by the Pioneer Institute says that METCO deserves better funding. (David Goldman/AP)

BOSTON -- A new report highlights the success of Massachusetts' voluntary urban-to-suburban busing program, known as METCO, and says the state must do more to support and expand it.

The report, released Tuesday by the right-leaning think tank the Pioneer Institute, urges the state to provide additional funding for METCO, to expand the program to other urban districts, and to regularly provide more information about the program's impact.

Ken Ardon, co-author of the report and chair of the economics department at Salem State University, says METCO, which buses about 3,300 non-white Boston and Springfield students to schools in surrounding, predominantly white suburbs, is a key way to support urban education in the state.

"I think that it's a good way to give parents an opportunity to send their kids to different schools," Ardon said in an interview. "METCO is just one piece of that, but I think it's one that's been pretty successful."

The Pioneer Institute says that in 2011, 88 percent of METCO students enrolled in higher education, compared with 81 percent across the state. The report also touts METCO's success in reducing the achievement gap.

“METCO students halved the achievement gap in both the 3rd grade reading and 6th grade math tests,” the report by the privately funded group found. “In sixth grade reading, virtually the same percentage of METCO students score proficient or higher as the commonwealth average.”

However, the academic successes of METCO students can not be fully contributed to the METCO program itself. Students who participate in METCO are typically signed up by parents before the age of 3, indicating a level of academic support from an early age.

The program has become so popular that it has a massive wait list of about 10,000 students from Boston and Springfield. The report, citing demand and the academic success of METCO students, calls for expanding the program in those two cities as well as into other urban districts such as Holyoke, Pittsfield and Worcester.

John Shandorf, associate director of METCO, would support expansion but believes it would prove difficult due to the program's current funding.

"I am a firm believer in education opportunities," Shandorf said. "But the apprehension, when there's discussion about expanding the program beyond Boston and Springfield, is is the Legislature going to appropriate more funds?"

According to the report, if adjusted for inflation, METCO's funding has fallen about 20 percent over the past 10 years.

"METCO is not adjusted for inflation," said study co-author Ardon. "So if METCO funding is level-funded each year, which is roughly what it has been, it's actually dropping in real terms."

In 2006, METCO received about $17.5 million in funding. Presently, METCO receives about $18.5 million in funding.

The Pioneer Institute report recommends that METCO funding become fully incorporated into the state's school funding formula, which is adjusted annually for inflation.

The report also calls on the state to conduct more research into the performance of METCO students.

"The Department of Elementary and Secondary Education should, I believe, encourage research into, how successful are the METCO students? In what ways does the program work in what ways does the program not work?" said Ardon. "I would really like to see better research."

Officials from the Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (DESE) said that a doctoral student is currently working with DESE to research METCO's effectiveness and that additional research is up to the Legislature to authorize.

Related: