Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

Social Studies Education In 'Crisis,' Says Mass. Council President

Gorman Lee, president of the Massachusetts Council for the Social Studies, warns that social studies education faces “a civic crisis.” (Wikimedia)
Gorman Lee, president of the Massachusetts Council for the Social Studies, warns that social studies education faces “a civic crisis.” (Wikimedia)

With the proliferation of high-stakes testing for English-language arts, math and science, educators in a non-tested area are concerned that their subject has been pushed aside.

In a message posted to the Massachusetts Council for the Social Studies' (MCSS) website in late March, president Gorman Lee says that social studies education in the state is in the midst of a "civic crisis."

"We've already heard so many of our students graduating from high school with limited knowledge about our government, how it functions and operates," Lee, who is also director of social studies for Braintree Public Schools, said in an interview. "There is a concern among social studies educators that the further marginalization of our subject area could lead to unintended consequences."

In his message posted to the MCSS site, Lee asked readers to respond to a survey about the status of the social studies program in their school districts.

While a number of respondents indicated district support for social studies programs, a number of the responses lamented the compression of English-language arts classes and social studies classes into a single "humanities" department.

"Every year, more schools are cutting their history courses and moving to a 'humanities' model in which students are taught ELA for double the time, and receive little to no solid history instruction," wrote one respondent. "This year alone, I know of four more middle schools moving in the direction of humanities."

"History is being severely impacted via cuts and neglect," a respondent from the same school district wrote. "Schools drop history altogether in favor of 'humanities.'"

Others specifically tied the decrease in social studies education to their district's focus on subjects with high-stakes testing.

"Social studies has been cut in the elementary schools. Instruction is down to about 45 minutes per week (science is the same) so time can be used to focus on ELA and math," a respondent from a different district wrote. "At the high school, social studies is taught for only two-thirds of the year while math and ELA are taught for the entire year."

In 2009, the Massachusetts Board of Elementary and Secondary Education decided to indefinitely suspend the implementation of a history and social science standardized assessment.

Facing financial constraints at the time, K-12 education Commissioner Mitchell Chester recommended the move and said it would help preserve existing MCAS tests for English language arts, math and science that are required by federal law.

"Administrators and school officials would invest more resources, personnel, professional development towards the subject areas that would be tested," said Lee. "Because history and social studies were not going to be tested it hasn't seemed that much of a priority."

Jacqueline Reis, spokesperson for the Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (DESE), says that the value the department places on history and social sciences is reflected in the Massachusetts curriculum frameworks.

"Ensuring that history and the social sciences are given adequate class time, that is an issue for local districts," Reis said in an email. "While the state standards laid out in the frameworks articulate what students should know and be able to do, it is up to districts and schools to figure out the best way to help students master them."

The Board of Elementary and Secondary Education currently has a working group for civic learning.

Lee is clear that a test isn't the solution for social studies he is looking for. Instead, he says, all subjects need to be valued in order to give students the education that they deserve.

"In the end what we want is for schools not to 'short shrift' social studies," said Lee.