State Assumes Control Of Holyoke Public Schools
FITCHBURG, Mass. -- The Massachusetts Board of Elementary and Secondary Education (BESE) voted Tuesday to place Holyoke Public Schools under state receivership.
"I want to make sure that people on the ground in Holyoke see it as an opportunity, because that's the reason we're there," said Commissioner Mitchell Chester, of the state's Department of Elementary and Secondary Education. "To give students in Holyoke a better chance."
In an 8-3 vote taken during a daylong meeting in central Massachusetts, the board declared the Holyoke school system a "chronically under-performing" Level 5 school district. Under state receivership, an appointed receiver, who reports directly to the commissioner, will develop a turnaround plan to enhance academic progress in the district.
Currently, Holyoke's on-time graduation rate is the lowest in the state.
The district will remain under receivership until it has improved to the point that the designation of “chronically under-performing” can be removed.
Three board members -- Ed Doherty, Mary Ann Stewart and Donald Willyard -- dissented to the vote. Doherty cited labor concerns, as the receiver has the right to force all teachers to reapply for their jobs.
Stewart and Willyard, the only two board members who claimed to have visited the school district following a troubling state review of Holyoke Public Schools released earlier this year, said they were happy with the on-the-ground progress they observed.
"I saw that the district review was not representative of the actual climate and culture of the school," said Willyard, the student representative on the board and an 11th grade student at Pioneer Charter in Everett. "They're on a very positive upswing and that's why I voted no."
Holyoke's graduation rate climbed from 49.5 percent in 2011 to 60.2 percent in 2014, but the new number is still the lowest graduation rate in the state. Similarly, the dropout rate has fallen but is still the second-highest dropout rate in Massachusetts, behind Springfield.
Both were reasons cited by board members for the vote on receivership.
"I'm disappointed by the way it came," Willyard said of the vote. "Now we need to move toward receivership in a positive way."
Holyoke joins Lawrence as the second public school district in four years to be taken over by the state.
The Holyoke Public Schools website lists a total of 10 schools in the district, including two high schools -- Holyoke and Dean Technical.
"We were hoping for a different outcome, from the beginning I was against receivership," said Devin Sheehan, vice-chair of the Holyoke school committee. "But what's important now moving forward is that we work as a community together."
Education officials said they have already begun interviewing potential receivers. For now, Chester will assume the role of acting receiver.
This post was updated at 4:25 p.m.