How Massachusetts Redefines Low-Income Students

BOSTON -- Under a new state metric to determine whether public school students are economically disadvantaged, far fewer Massachusetts students will be counted as living in poverty, according to state data.
For years Massachusetts has used students' eligibility for free or reduced lunch to measure if students qualified as "low-income." Now, Massachusetts will scrap that method and instead deem students "economically disadvantaged" only if the student participates in one or more specific state-administered social welfare programs: food stamps, foster care, medicaid or transitional assistance for families with dependent children.
The altered method of counting students is expected to have major policy implications as fewer students across the state now count as low-income. Some educators are concerned that the new policy may inadvertently take away funding from districts and disenfranchise certain families.
Changes In District Measurements
The change does not reflect any real changes in family income, just a change in how the measurement is taken. It was first reported by the Boston Globe.
Now, less than half of Boston school students are regarded as being from impoverished homes, compared with the previous figure of about three-quarters. Chelsea, Lawrence, and other cities also saw big drops. Statewide rates dropped, but less dramatically.
City Councilor Tito Jackson, chair of the education committee for the Boston city council, believes the change in metrics can have substantial impacts.
"What you're looking at are metrics that do not encompass all of the people who need all of the assistance," says Jackson. "We know that not every family that is eligible for social welfare benefits actually take advantage of the programs. So we're missing a huge swath and that's why you see an over 25 percent reduction in the city of Boston alone."
Under the new measurement, over half of Massachusetts' 22 cities with populations over 50,000 have seen their school districts plummet from majority "low-income" students to districts where less than half of their students count as "economically disadvantaged."
Over three-quarters of the student body in Revere was previously counted as low-income, now less than 40 percent will be counted as economically disadvantaged.
In Lawrence, 92 percent of the students served by the district were previously counted as low-income, but now fewer than two-thirds of the students will be considered impoverished under the new measurement.
"In the long-term we have seen less funding from the state level heading toward Boston but the other component that we need to look at is what it means on a school-by-school level," "It's going to add a great deal of pressure at the school site level."
Policy Implications
It's widely known that students from low-income households face more learning challenges than students from more affluent homes. For that reason, the number of poor students in a district is used to determine the money behind a number of district programs and activities.
A change to income levels' calculations can bring changes to how that money is distributed.
The new measure is expected to have major implications in how state aid for disadvantaged students is distributed, district eligibility for grant programs that require poverty data and the amount that school systems may receive in reimbursements from the state for construction projects.
It also could influence district and school performance accountability, as schools with fewer students counted as poor may be expected to perform at higher levels on state assessments.
"We're not making this change to say that we've solved poverty, we're making this change because the data that we had available is no longer available. We need something else," says Jeff Wulfson, deputy commissioner for the Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (DESE), the state agency behind the metric change.
For decades, Massachusetts has used free or reduced-price lunch qualifications as the standard for measuring poverty in public schools. But many school districts across the state, often in high-poverty areas, are now part of a federal program to offer free meals to all students regardless of income.
Currently, schools in 22 of Massachusetts 104 districts participate in the meal program. An additional 32 are eligible to participate and state officials wanted a new way to track student income.
"The major alternative we considered was continuing to require [free lunch eligibility] data. The problem is that if you don't have the incentive of a free lunch for a family, our expectation is that the response rate on the forms would not be very high," says Wulfson.
Invisible Populations
Heeshan Berents-Weeramuni, co-chair of the Boston Public Schools Citywide Parents Council, says that the new policy may render invisible people who once qualified for aid.
“The new formula just simply doesn't take into account certain families and students,” says Weeramuni. "You’re not really acknowledging the fact that people continue to be poor. You’re just simply not counting them as existing."
The new methodology, he says, leaves no room for families who have not tapped the welfare programs -- either out of pride, lack of knowledge, incorrect applications or for legal reasons.
Documented immigrants are not eligible for food stamps until they have lived in the country for 5 years, although children under 18 are. Undocumented immigrants are not eligible to participate in any state-administered programs.
"Some of our neediest students who actually qualify for higher weights and for more support are not being counted and that’s a problem," says Berents Weeramuni. "Not only are they not receiving funding but every single student in that school that these families attend also don’t get the additional amount of funding."
Low-Income Weighted Funding
Weeramuni says that a number of Boston schools have reported that due to the new formula they are facing foreseeable funding losses.
"This is going to result, for some schools, in a loss of programming. Which makes them less desirable for families to enroll in, which basically means they'll lose more programs which will be even less desirable for more families," says Weeramuni. "There's this kind of death spiral that happens and it's incredibly worrying."
Public schools in Boston, and throughout the state, are often given additional funding if the number of low-income students that they serve pass a certain percentage.
For instance, schools in Boston that educate students living in poverty at a higher level than 60 percent receive extra funding. Schools with high concentrations of students living in poverty may also receive federal grants.
DESE officials say they are working with federal and state officials to come up with funding formulas that take their new metric into account.
"Our largest concern with any proposed change in how students living in poverty are measured is that our district not be financially penalized in the distribution of state aid for public education," said John McDonough, Boston's interim superintendent, in a statement. "We also want to make sure that measures of poverty reflect the demographics of the students we serve."