Learning Lab
This is an archive of WBUR’s Learning Lab, which covered education in Massachusetts from 2013 to 2016.

Reporter's Notebook

State To Receive Initial Report On Adequately Funding Public Schools

The state committee that is crafting recommendations for how the state should adequately fund public schools approved a preliminary report to submit to the Massachusetts Legislature on Tuesday. (Ted S. Warren/AP)
The state committee that is crafting recommendations for how the state should adequately fund public schools approved a preliminary report to submit to the Massachusetts Legislature on Tuesday. (Ted S. Warren/AP)

The state committee that will craft recommendations for how the state should adequately fund public schools approved a preliminary report to submit to the Massachusetts Legislature on Tuesday.

At the State House meeting of the Foundation Budget Review Commission (FBRC), members put the final touches on a report that includes some initial findings on school districts' health care costs and spending on special education students.

The committee members also agreed to include in the report that the FBRC plans to analyze a number of other areas, including costs associated with lowering class sizes in early grades, wraparound services, extended learning time and educating English-language learners.

The foundation budget, which the commission is reviewing, is the base level of per-pupil funding that the state has determined each district needs to provide students with an adequate education. It was established in 1993 as part of the Education Reform Act. Since then it has not been adjusted, except for inflation.

Currently, major gaps are present between what the foundation budget says districts need and what districts are actually spending.

A report by MassBudget, an advisory member of the FBRC, gathered and analyzed data from the state’s 328 operating districts. The study found the current funding formula does not reflect increased health insurance and special education costs.

“The consequence of that in the classroom is that districts are spending well below the foundation budget assumption on regular education teachers,” Luc Schuster, deputy director of MassBudget and author of that study, told Learning Lab in January. “Many schools in the commonwealth have larger class sizes than were intended originally, teachers are having fewer prep periods to prepare and collaborate with each other between classes.”

The biggest point of contention at the meeting came as Massachusetts Business Alliance for Education representative Joe Esposito recommended the creation of an "innovation fund" in the state funding formula that schools or districts would compete for in order to access the funds.

He said that having districts lay out specific plans for the money will make it more likely that the state Legislature would allocate the additional funds.

Others, including Massachusetts Association of School Committees board president Patrick Francomano said that introducing a competitive component that will only give some districts funds if they agree to use the funds in a certain way goes against the foundation budget's design.

"The foundation budget as it was established is an entitlement budget. It's what do we need based upon our population of students, what is an adequate amount of money to be spending," said Francomano. "To introduce a competitive component to the foundation budget is really inconsistent with its purpose."

More so, Francomano said it assumes that the reason that districts seek money is because they have wasted their funds, not that they are using the existing funds to cover raising costs that the foundation budget does not currently cover.

"When you're attaching strings to an allocation, that's almost implying that we're not managing it well," said Francomano. "From a professional standpoint I resent that."

The FBRC will submit the final, public version of their preliminary report to the Legislature before the end of the month. The FBRC plans to continue meeting over the summer.

Despite the Education Reform Act mandating that the governor appoint a foundation budget review commission every three years to review the way in which foundation budgets are calculated, it's been over 10 years since the last formal review commission issued a report.

A final comprehensive report will be submitted by this commission by Nov. 1.