Boston Expects 125 Teachers Unassigned To Their Own Classroom

BOSTON -- With one week until school begins, Boston school officials expect about 125 Boston Public Schools (BPS) teachers to have no classroom assignment this fall, at an estimated cost of over $10.5 million in salary and benefits.
Although lacking classes to teach, the 125 teachers will remain on the BPS payroll because they have earned "permanent" status. Teachers will work alternative assignments over the course of the year until vacancies in the district occur.
"As classrooms open up either due to enrollment changes, retirement or teachers going out on leave, we're lucky," said Emily Kalejs Qazilbash, BPS assistant superintendent for human capital. "We have this pool of strong teachers who we can then match to positions."
Until classrooms open up, school officials say teachers will be assigned among 28 district schools where they may serve as substitutes, assist in academic interventions or help in other teachers' classrooms.
The 2014-2015 school year began with 110 unassigned teachers, about two-thirds of whom remained without a classroom all year.
'These Are Not Discards'
According to district numbers, 163 teachers were unassigned to their own classrooms as of Aug. 27. School officials say they've filled some positions since then and expect to continue until school begins.
For the teachers left in this "excess pool," it's largely not a question of bad teaching. According to Boston Teachers Union, two-thirds of those teachers who received evaluations rate as proficient or higher.
"These are not teachers who are in this situation because of something of their own making," said Richard Stutman, president of the union. "They are women returning from maternity leave, they are teachers who have been in schools taken over by the state. These could be excellent teachers who happened to be in a school that was underperforming."
A disproportionate share of the unplaced veteran teachers are black. According to the union, 69 of the 163 unplaced teachers, or 42 percent, are black. Black teachers make up 21 percent of the BPS teaching force.
This comes on the heels of a study released earlier this year, that found, in general, that Boston schools largely display a widespread lack of cultural competency when teaching black and Latino students.
"These are people who have been recruited themselves to teach in BPS. These are people who are experienced," Stutman said. "These are not discards."
Hiring Process Allows Schools To Reach Beyond The District
A hiring process adopted before last school year allows for outside hires, even if current teachers haven't been placed yet.
"When we changed to mutual consent hiring we expected and we budgeted for a system that would mean that not every teacher would earn a job," said BPS' Qazilbash. "We expected to be right here, right now, at this point of time."
It used to be that schools could not hire from outside the system until all of the internal candidates had been placed. Under that practice, the hiring of new teachers would often take place in the summer -- a time when, school officials say, many of the best candidates already had jobs.
Beginning last year, school officials began to take advantage of a seldom-used clause in the union contract: Principals can consider teachers from outside the district for positions they classify as requiring special skills or extra duty, regardless of whether internal candidates are vying for the job.
The extra duty could include tasks like tutoring after school, where teachers receive a $1,250 stipend in return for the extra hours.
The stipends totaled $1.2 million at the beginning of last school year. The district recently turned to private funders to offset the price of training and recruitment programs for teachers and principals.
While union contract rules formerly dictated where teachers get placed, under the new model, district teachers must actively apply to school openings. And now, they may be competing with teachers outside of the district.
Some teachers without assignments did not apply to any schools, Qazilbath said.
"We believe strongly that a teacher should actively choose which school they will be teaching in," Qazilbath said. "And a school team -- which includes the school principal, as well as teachers and parents on a council -- should engage in a rigorous hiring process."
Last year the union filed a grievance about the new hiring practice. It is still in arbitration.